Dundee United v Aberdeen Review
Dundee United v Aberdeen Tactical Review
Lineups/setup
Goodwin made four changes from last week's defeat v Ross County. For his first match in charge, Birighitti was reinstated in goal, McMann, Freeman and Harkes also came into the team with Newman, Smith, Fotheringham and Djoum dropping out of the starting eleven. A new manager saw us return to the 343 formation we've used under Fox. Birighitti was back in goal with a back three of Edwards on the right, Mulgrew in the middle with McMann on the left. Freeman and Behich were the wing backs. Levitt and Sibbald were in the centre of midfield with Harkes and McGrath supporting Fletcher up top.
I was interested to see what lineup Goodwin would put out and wasn't totally surprised by any selections made. I assumed Birighitti was back in goal for experience over Newman. Freeman in for Smith was a slight surprise but was required. At this stage of the season, I'm not bothered by who plays most of the time, it's more about the application and attitude of those who do play.
Aberdeen were unchanged from their last game v Livingston. They played in a 433 formation with Gorter in goal, a back four of McCrorie, MacDonald, Pollock and MacKenzie. Ramadani was more of the sitter in midfield with Shinnie and Clarkson ahead of him. Duncan played off the right with Duk on the left. Miovski was the lone striker.
Good shape about United
United's shape off the ball was fairly simple. Drop off and allow the Aberdeen centre backs possession then look to press the ball once it gets played into the midfield or to their full backs. Fletcher looked to drop onto Ramadani to prevent the ball being played centrally. Both MacDonald and Pollock were reluctant to drive forward with the ball and commit any United defenders so resorted to lots of side to side passes around the back or for the big diagonal switch to opposite side winger/full back. Even both their full backs were hesitant of stepping in with the ball and often played backwards.
With Harkes and McGrath tucked in narrow, it prevented Aberdeen from playing penetrative passes through our lines to the likes of Clarkson who was looking for space between the United defence and midfield. United were able to shift across well and frustrate Aberdeen who would often force the longer passes or play the "safer" passes.
In possession United weren't looking to play out from the back. The plan was simple, look for Fletcher or get switches of play to open up crossing opportunities for Fletcher. Behich and Freeman both looked to get into advanced positions to occupy the Aberdeen wide players and pin them back. With Harkes and McGrath in the half spaces, it gave the Aberdeen full backs a problem about who to mark if our wing backs were advanced. They would often mark the central player to allow space out wide. This is why we ended up getting so many crosses into the Aberdeen box.
Any example of this from the Aberdeen full backs was highlighted in the 2nd half with the Behich chance. (I know I'm skipping forward a bit but it's the best example of it)
McGrath is central when he brings the ball down. McCrorie comes all the way with him into the centre of the park. Behich is already recognised the space in the wide area and begins to power forward. McGrath pops the ball off to Sibbald who plays it to Behich in space to drive forward. We are unlucky that we don't open the scoring from this opportunity.
McGrath and Harkes positioning also meant when we went long to Fletcher, we had players closer to him for knock downs and flick on's which allowed us to gain territory in their half and sustain attacks.
Half time United 0-0 Aberdeen
At the break, the only disappointment was that we weren't ahead. Aberdeen offered very little. Our shape was compact and looked dangerous on transition. Although we maybe didn't create lots of goal scoring opportunities, we were the much better team.
Aberdeen tactical tweaks
Aberdeen made a few tactical tweaks to their setup in the 2nd half. Both their wide players, Duk and Duncan were playing slightly more narrow than in the first half. This positioning, similar to Harkes/McGrath were playing for us, posed questions to our outside centre backs and wing backs as who the responsibility to mark in certain areas changes. Does the wing back follow into middle and possibly leave space out wide? or does they pass the player on the centre back? With space opening up behind them?
It also allowed their full backs to creep into higher positions forcing McGrath and Harkes deeper which could open up spaces for Clarkson between the lines as he was pushed higher to connect to Miovski.
0-1 Aberdeen Duk
Aberdeen took the lead against the run of play with their first big chance of the game. Duk chases down Edwards, who hesitates with his clearance. The ball breaks for Duk who drives in and finishes brilliantly to put Aberdeen ahead.
This goal obviously comes from Edwards just taking too long to decide what he wants to do with the ball. He has a couple of opportunities to deal with the ball but credit to Duk who puts him under pressure and gets his reward for this effort to close Edwards down. Edwards is slightly unlucky with the break of the ball going into the space directly behind him rather than going out for a throw-in/goal kick like it would in similar scenarios in other games but Duk does earn the break for his desire.
Once the ball breaks into the space, Edwards then has to turn to react while Duk's forward momentum and pace has him in on front foot. I think Edwards could probably take one for the team here and bring Duk down before he gains proper control and gets into the penalty area. Unless it was a reckless challenge, I don't think there could have been any red cards discussion.
Once in the box, Edwards can't touch him and is clearly trying to avoid any contact. Mulgrew coming across to cover now needs to force Duk to have a shot from that angle. As much as he is close on goal, the angle is tight plus he is still under pressure. However, Mulgrew's body shape is poor as he is unbalanced and almost over commits. (No confidence for keeper to save a shot from this angle?)
This allows Duk to just take a touch inside which opens up the goal. Mulgrew's feet are planted and can't react to the quick change of direction from Duk. If you watch Mulgrew in this moment once he is planted he doesn't move at all. He pivots on the spot rather than moving his feet towards the ball.
Subs/Change of shape
At the 70th minute mark, United made a double change. Sibbald and Harkes off for Anaku and Djoum. This meant a slight tweak in formation from a 343 to a 352 with Anaku partnering Fletcher and Djoum joining Levitt and McGrath in a three man midfield.
1-1 McGrath Penalty
United got level from the penalty spot thanks to a composed McGrath finish.
Not much tactical here but in the build up, we do have lots of bodies around the ball. Not only does this help us keep possession but it means we can counter press the ball if possession is lost. Anaku's reaction to the loss of possession is really good and he gets his reward for his alertness.
1-2 Aberdeen McCrorie
Aberdeen retook the lead after some nice play down their left hand side allowed them to fire a ball across for McCrorie who fired Aberdeen ahead.
Djoum goes flying out to put pressure on the ball but over-commits which allows Hayes to play a clever pass inside to Clarkson.

Once Clarkson receives the ball. Freeman and Edwards need to communicate who's going to the ball and who is covering but they both seem to get in each others way. At the back post, United have plenty of bodies back but are slightly flat footed.
Clarkson's close control is very good as he drives to the byline. Edwards and Freeman collide and can't prevent the cross. All a bit too easy and standoffish. McCrorie is now in a bit of space looking to peel away from Behich.
Both Behich and McMann are not tight enough to either of the Aberdeen players. Behich has retreated back onto the line for some reason and McMann is static. The United defenders here too worried about marking the space rather than the Aberdeen players. Birighitti could maybe save it as it's close to the middle of the goal but possibly being harsh as it was struck powerfully from close range.
1-3 Aberdeen- Watkins
Aberdeen sealed the win with a nice finish from Watkins.
Aberdeen clip the ball down the channel for Watkins to chase. Edwards is favourite to the ball here but with Watkins being slightly ahead of him and on his inside, he needs to be careful. Clarkson is lots of space behind the United midfield here. If Watkins wins the ball then Clarkson becomes a big danger.
Watkins bullies Edwards off the ball and plays the ball to Clarkson who plays it quickly back to Watkins, who has reacted to attack the space inside. Edwards is slow to react from the original challenge. McMann now needs to come across and recognise the danger and cover his fellow centre backs.
From the wider angle McMann has no other Aberdeen player to deal with so he can step across to put pressure on the ball but doesn't. McMann plants his feet and almost encourages Watkins to try and shot around him rather than attempting to block the shot.
McMann's stance is static (mannequin like). Not only does it encourage Watkins to shot around him but he then blocks the sight of Birighitti, who doesn't have a clear line of the ball. Possibly Birighitti could get across quicker to make the save but he is un-sighted and sees the ball late due to McMann blocking his view.
Full time United 1-3 Aberdeen
Frustrating as our performance merited more. Defensive mistakes being punished by Aberdeen and not taking any chances we did create meant we lost again. Our shape was better and our application was much improved but we can't concede the goals we concede and expect to win any games.
My Man of the Match
I'm actually not going to give a man of the match as I don't think we had any standouts and it was more a general team performance.
Don't think Birighitti could do much with the goals. Possibly the 3rd one but he was un-sighted and don't think any blame could be attached to him. Edwards was solid in the first half then the mistake for their first goal clearly knocked his confidence. He was scared of Duk and was left isolated against him. Needs to do better. Mulgrew was alright. He's come under heavy critzism but felt he put in a solid performance in the middle of the back three. McMann went about his work quietly. Felt we dealt with Duncan fairly easily and covered his teammates well but did think he was far too static at their 2nd/3rd goals. Freeman worked away. First half was fairly solid. Got into good crossing positions and put some decent deliveries into the box. 2nd half, I thought he struggled to get forward. He struggled with the power of Duk as the 2nd half wore on, even more so once booked. Behich was similar to Freeman. Looked dangerous in the first half with high positioning. 2nd half, he still tried to get forward but felt Aberdeen done well to stifle it. Levitt was very good first half. Not so much his in possession ability but his off the ball work. Looked interested and up for the fight. Nicking and intercepting well. 2nd half did seem to pass him by but signs of the old Levitt in the first half performance at least. Sibbald done a power of work as usual but felt he looked a bit sluggish on the ball. Felt his touch and passing wasn't quite as accurate as normal. Covered lots of ground and won some key battles in midfield. I felt McGrath struggled at times. He worked very hard but just felt in possession, he was wasteful. Took his penalty well and hopefully that will give him confidence going forward. I thought Harkes was effective. His energy to get closer to Fletcher was important in getting us up the park in the first half especially. Harkes can sometimes look like he's going through the motions but he looked sharp and switched on which makes him look so much better. Just that final decision or moment that lets him down. Was always going to tire after coming back from injury. Fletcher was a handful for the Aberdeen defence all night. His hold up play was excellent and with having support around him, he was able to link the play very well. However, he did have good opportunities to score and needs to be taking them.
Anaku made a good impact from the bench. He provided energy and a directness which we lack at times. He caused a few problems for the Aberdeen defence. Djoum came on in the midfield and I felt the game was too quick for his liking. Worked hard when he came on but composure on the ball was lacking.
Thoughts
New manager but same outcome. Deserved something from the game but individual mistakes being punished and not taking our chances at the other end, ultimately costing us again. Our shape was good and we caused Aberdeen lots of problems but we can't keep shooting ourselves in the foot with mistakes. I didn't think Aberdeen were great but credit to them for taking their chances and capitalising on these errors.
The setup and way we played was what I was expecting from Goodwin. Not looking to overplay and looking to move the ball forward quickly. The team did look more organised and were working a lot harder out of possession. We played in a similar setup that Fox played the majority of his time as manager but with structure and purpose to our play.
I did think we could/should have made a change earlier as our intensity began to drop in the 2nd half especially after their goal. I think a Fotheringham or Niskanen from the inside winger position could have been an option for something a bit different or to provide some pace and directness. However, bringing on Anaku did have a similar affect. As much as it would have been a slightly strange decision I would have possibly considered bringing Smith on in midfield instead of Djoum just to give some more energy/mobility. Djoum gives us the physical presence but alongside Levitt we needed better mobility and ground coverage. This is when Aberdeen began to gain more control of the match.
Going forward, Goodwin will still have the same issues as Fox and will have to find the solution to them or we are as good as down. Overall we played well but all that good work was undone by defensive mistakes. Can he sort out these defensive issues? How can he get goals into the team? Problems Goodwin will need to solve soon. It was a positive performance but at this stage of the season and our current position, performances are redundant.... points are what we desperately need.
Livingston away midweek will be tough as it's a place we are notoriously not good at but they've been on a poor run also so the opportunity is there.
Thank you and I hope you've enjoyed reading this review.
.jpg)







Comments
Post a Comment