Tactical Review of United 21/22

Tactical Review of United! 

After a ninth place finish in our first season back in the top flight, Micky Mellon left the club and was replaced by head of tactical performance Tam Courts. A relative unknown and an unproven choice at this level which left the majority of fans questioning the decision to appoint him. After a successful but unconvincing league cup group campaign, our opening game of the league season was away to Aberdeen. After a passive and disjointed performance which resulted in a comfortable 2-0 win for the Dons, Courts found himself under heavy scrutiny early in his tenure.  
However, in the long run, this result turned out to be a blessing in disguise for the team and for Courts as it forced him into a change of setup going forward which showed his ability to recognise his mistakes and to then correct it. 

Before looking at the change of formation, I want to look at why this Aberdeen result was the catalyst for the change and how Courts turned this mistake into a positive throughout the season. 

So why didn't the 343 work? 

United set up in a 343 formation against Aberdeen on that day. A back three of Edwards on the right, Mulgrew in the centre with Reynolds on the left. Smith and Robson as the wing backs. Harkes and Butcher as centre midfielders with Clark and Pawlett supporting lone striker Shankland. 
Lineup v Aberdeen

The team just didn't look happy in this setup during this game. In the back three, our defence looked uncomfortable and uneasy. When playing as the right or left centre back, these players need to be comfortable if dragged out into wide positions and have a mobility to deal with tricky wide players. Neither of Edwards or Reynolds suited this role. Both not very mobile and want to stay central. Edwards would often overcompensate this by saying extremely narrow and Reynolds would be left exposed out wide without the pace to recover.
 A great example of this was the 2nd Aberdeen goal that day. 
Reynolds out wide
Reynolds is dragged out wide to deal with Ramsay and gets beaten by some lovely skill from the Aberdeen man. 
Edwards narrow
As the ball comes into the box Edwards is too narrow. Overcompensating because he isn't sure exactly where he is meant to be. Ramirez gets a free header to make it 2-0

By both side centre backs not being overly comfortable, the wing backs would be asked to protect the channel pass, meaning they couldn't aggressively press high up the park resulting in United dropping deeper as a unit. The wing backs would be left with too much ground to make up for when in possession as their starting position would be so deep resulting in us not having a great deal of width going forward. 

The centre midfield that day was Butcher and Harkes. In this shape, the two midfielders are having to hold position defensively. This prevented Harkes from pressing higher up the park and engaging with the opposition. Spaces and gaps would open up due to the two having to cover so much ground and would be left often outnumbered in the middle of the park. To help deal with this, the attacking midfielders would drop into wide areas creating a 541. This gave us no real out ball and usually meant a turnover of possession back to Aberdeen. 

Gaps in midfield
Gaps in midfield

The performance left United fans concerned that this was the start of what would be a long season. A comfortable 2-0 win for an Aberdeen team who didn't need to get out of 2nd gear. This opened up questions for the coaching team for the following game. 

Tactical Switch- Mindset Shift

The following week against Rangers, United switched to a narrow 433. This setup gave United much better balance across the team. The centre backs who were left exposed at Pittodrie, were now protected with support around them, not only by the full backs but also by a sitting defensive midfielder in front of the defence. The Full backs were now able to support the attacking wide players higher up the park without having the full responsibility of needing to provide the width for the team if they didn't like they would in a 343.
With now having a three man midfield, United were now able to match up against most opponents and wouldn't leave us outnumbered in the centre of the park. It allowed us to get better numbers around the ball to put pressure on the opposition during transition as it gave players like Harkes and Fuchs the licence to go hunting after the ball rather than being forced to hold position more than if in a two man midfield. 

The lone striker could would be flanked by two inside forwards who would mainly play inside to open up space wide for the supporting runs of the full backs. This also allowed players to get closer to the central striker and preventing them from becoming isolated and disconnected from the rest of the team. 
Rangers line up

United worked hard and defended brilliantly with good structure off the ball. The tactical plan worked well as Rangers struggled to break down a compact and disciplined United team. A 1-0 victory resulted in a huge mindset shift for Courts. What this result had shown was that not only could we win games but that the players could execute tactical plans from the management team to nullify the then Champions. It also showed that Courts was adaptable in systems and wasn't too stubborn to stick with a setup that didn't work. 

So what made the 433 work? 

Although we did mix it up tactically early in the season (442 in some games) our form really picked up when we consistently played the 433. The balance of the team was better with players playing positions that was best suited for their attributes (majority of the time) 

433

Defensive Structure

One of the most important aspects of United play in the first half of the season was the high energy style we played in and out of possession. This was down to having key players such as Fuchs and Harkes being higher up the park which allowed them to apply pressure in transition quickly and win plenty of 2nd balls. The ground that these two covered meant we always had good numbers around the ball to apply this pressure. United would look to immediately counter press when possession was lost to force mistakes by the opposition or to force them backwards to allow United to recover in shape. 

Here's an example of getting good numbers around the ball against Rangers. Working hard to cut off the short passing options to force the mistake or backwards pass. 
 Numbers around the ball
Here's another example v Hearts. Lots of bodies around the ball putting pressure on the Hearts players. Suffocating them to force the turnover in possession. 
Numbers around the ball

Here's an example of United being able to win 2nd balls with these numbers around the ball. At Parkhead, the ball breaks in the midfield where Harkes is able to pick up the ball. Look at the number of United players ahead of the ball and the amount of space Harkes has. 
2nd balls

This example is away at Hibs. Ball breaks into midfield where United have numerous players ready to pick up the 2nd ball. 
2nd balls

Once the play was forced backwards or United were behind the ball in shape, we would look to pick and choose our moments to press. Sometimes this could leave us being slightly passive when the opposition had the ball at the back but we would set the trap for the passes into the midfield then we would look to jump and put pressure on the ball. This meant we would remain compact behind the ball and make it harder for the opposition to break us down. Forcing teams to play around our shape, where we could then shift across and cut off forward passes from there or force high passes forward which suited the likes of Edwards and Mulgrew who are dominant in the air. 

Compact
Compact

Pressing Structure 

The front three would stay narrow with their positioning. This could help them block of central passes and entice the ball wide. This also gave our attacking players the ability to press the opposition centre backs if the opportunity arises. If the ball was played to the opposition full back, it would either be the wide player who deals with it or the centre midfielder would come across to put pressure on the ball. 

Here's a few example's of our narrow shape from the attacking players. This half and half sort of position gave them the opportunity to press different players dependant on where the ball went. 

Here's a quick example of the wide player pressing the opposition full back or wing back. The opposite side attacking player inside, narrow ready to press. 

Here's a clip of our high intensity pressing from the front three against Hibs. Forcing the defender back and having to play quickly under pressure. This forces a turnover of possession. 

If the ball the wide attacking player jumped up to press the opposition centre back then the centre midfielder would be required to come across to the full back to cover/press. This would require lots of effort and work rate from the midfield but if done correctly United could pounce and attack quickly if we managed to turn over possession due to the high positioning of the attacking players.
Midfield press the FBs

Here's a simplistic example against Hibs at start of the season. The Hibs centre back has the ball. Clark, Niskanen and Pawlett would not engage with the ball until the time is right. Niskanen and Pawlett could drop onto the deeper Hibs centre midfielders, preventing central penetration. This forces the ball wide and allows United to engage and full press when Harkes/Fuchs would step up to press the full back. 
Centre mids pressing fb

Attacking Organization 

In the early part of the season, United would look to build the play from the back and play through the thirds of the pitch. The defensive midfielder (Usually Levitt) would try to control and dictate the play. Having this control was important for allowing other players to get into higher positions to affect the opposition. The full backs would look to support in advanced positions. This would allow the attacking midfielders to come inside and pick up pockets of space in the half spaces. 
Attacking organisation

An example of this was in our League cup game against Hibs. Pawlett has come inside which has opened space out wide for the full back Freeman to push forward into. This sort of movement caused problems for the opposition full back as they don't know whether to track the run inside or pass the player on and deal with the full back in the wide area. 

This wasn't a fixed move from United, the front three had licence to move fluidly and move into positions that could cause problems. This would often depend on the players preference. Niskanen for example would likely stay wider to hold the width while someone like Pawlett would prefer to drift inside to receive the ball in the half spaces. Clark would look to drop deeper to receive the ball as well, this could open out to in runs from the likes of Pawlett, Niskanen or even a deep run from someone like Harkes. 

This is an example of the fluid movement within this shape. If the attacking midfielder stays wide then the central midfielder can push more advanced into the half space but if the Attacking midfielder plays in the half space then that's the trigger for the full back to get higher. It's all about being able to occupy the opposition defence and getting players into higher positions. We wouldn't be able to get these players into higher positions unless we had some level of control when in possession. 
fluid shape

Issues with formation resulting in poor form

After a terrific first quarter of the season, our form began to stumble as teams started to become more used to our setup and find solutions to get exploit us. Although we lost to St Johnstone at the end of October (which was mainly down to rotating the squad and Zander Clark having a great game). The first game which showed United's vulnerabilities was away at Tynecastle against Hearts at the start of November. Defensively as a team we were poor that day and was exploited by an impressive Hearts team.  

Hearts were playing in a 343 that day and were able to exploit our pressing strategy by moving the ball quickly and bypassing our wide attacking players press. This had a knock on effect to the centre midfielder pressing the Hearts wing back. This quick passing meant it gave United lots of ground to cover and would leave gaps and space for Hearts to control the possession well. 

Niskanen pressing SouttarHarkes to Moore

Here's an example from the game. Niskanen presses Souttar who has the composure to play quickly to the wing back. Fuchs who is the next out to press, is just behind the play which allows Moore to take his time to control the ball and look to find a pass. United are just a yard or two off the pace which allowed Hearts the ability to play passes without being pressured. 

Being able to bypass our press meant our midfield was overran and gaps were left in front of the defence leaving them exposed to the quick attacking movement Hearts had. This result lead to cracks starting to show with this system. Teams had looked to have "figured it out". 

With key injuries and players being unavailable, United's squad started to get stretched. Our midfield balance wasn't as good and we began to be exploited in the centre of the park more often. Lacking a natural defensive midfielder meant we had no one able to sit and protect the defence effectively. 

Tony Watt's goal against us at the end of November for Motherwell is a prime example of this. There's a turnover of possession but our midfield shape was too expansive allowing Motherwell to penetrate through the middle of our shape quickly and run at our defence. 
midfield imbalance

More gaps would begin to open in front of the defence due to lack of "defensive mindset" from players not used to having this responsibility of cover and protecting the defence. Our pressing wasn't as effective and our general shape began to be disjointed as we entered into December. 
central penetration
The opposition midfield were finding it too easy to penetrate through our shape and to get wrong side of our midfield either by passing between us or runs off midfielders. 
runners off the midfield

We also had issues with teams man-marking Levitt out of the game. With Levitt being a key part of the way we played, teams started to make sure they prevented him getting on the ball to dictate play. United struggled to find the solution on what to do if Levitt couldn't dictate. This would often force United into going longer which suited the opposition due to United's lack of physical presence up top. 
Levitt man marked
Levitt Man Marked

This also forced Levitt to drop very deep to receive the ball from the centre backs and sometimes even the goalkeeper. This could be the trigger for other players moving into space to drag the opposition about however, United would be caught overplaying and unable to play through the thirds. 

Although this example is from the St Mirren game after the break, it still shows the issue. Levitt dropping deeper than he needs to be to receive the ball which doesn't affect the St Mirren shape as it's in front of them. 
Levitt dropping deep

Levitt being unavailable a spell before the break meant our possession play seemed to disintegrate with no real structure or idea of how to break through teams. Asking players such as Glass, Hoti or Harkes to play the way Levitt plays wasn't suitable.  

After a poor run of results leading into the Winter break. The January window would be crucial for getting players back fit and reinforcements to bring the season back on track. 

Change of System- 352

With striking options such as McNulty coming back from injury and Watt signing at the end of the January window, we now had players suitable of playing two up top. With Graham coming back from his unsuccessful loan at Dunfermline, we also now had more natural cover for left centre back. Losing Fuchs was a big blow and we struggled to replace that energy even more so when Harkes got injured in March. 

352
352
352

The difference when changing to a back three system this time compared to earlier in the season was that it didn't leave anyone in positions unsuitable for them. The back three selections would often be better with a combination of the likes of Graham, McMann, Neilson, Butcher and even Smith being used as the right or left centre back. Edwards at times would still be used as a right centre back which wasn't ideal but we definitely had better suited players in those roles than before. Better mobility meant that it allowed the wing backs to be much more aggressive with their positioning and pressing. We certainly looked get the wing backs higher up the park. 
Niskanen high
Wing backs high
Aggressive wing backs

We had a better structure to our midfield three during the 2nd half of the season in general as we played players that suited their attributes more. Signing McDonald gave us that bit of steel and defensive positioning we desperately needed. He may not have been as mobile but his experience and composure on the ball helped regain better shape. Having McDonald and even Mulgrew right at the end of the season playing as this defensive midfielder helped Levitt become more effective. Levitt was given the license to drift and be the playmaker for the team. The other midfielder could make runs further forward and connect with the strikers. This would usually be Harkes or Meekison. 
Midfield shape
Midfield shape

Our pressing structure was very similar to the 433. When the ball went wide then the wing back would engage the ball if possible, if not then the centre midfielder would come across to put pressure on the ball. 

Here's an example v Rangers where Barisic has the ball and is pressed by the centre midfielder (Mochrie) this is due to Smith (out of picture) being pinned back by the Rangers wide man so can't engage higher up the park in case the ball gets played behind him and takes him out of the play. 
centre mid pressing

This is an example of the wing back engaging the wide player. Niskanen playing at left wing back can engage with the Celtic attacker due to no players behind him to occupy and be pinned by. 
WB pressing

Our front two would pick and choose when to press but more often than not would drop deeper to protect the space between the units. This did leave us often unable to put good enough pressure on the opposition defenders but prevented central penetration. This created an issue of becoming too passive at times and allowing teams to get easy possession at the back and find a rhythm into the game. 
strikers dropping deep
strikers dropping deeper

Overall thoughts

From a tactical point of view, this was the sort of season I was expecting. With a new manager who hasn't managed at this level before, there was always going to be teething problems. Taking time for players to adjust to what Courts wanted and vice versa. One thing I like about Courts is his positivity and the ability to adapt to any mistakes previously made. In the past, United have had managers who are arrogant and wouldn't change a system or make key decisions regarding selections even if things weren't working but Courts has shown he is willing to make those decisions and changes if things needed. 

Yes it hasn't been as good as we would have liked on an attacking sense but he has still be able to get us organised and performing at a good level. We have been able to execute tactical plans well in games that shows his tactical nous as well as showing that the players are playing for him. All things considering, he and the players have done an excellent job securing 4th and European football next season. 

Going forward into 22/23

Replacing key players will be crucial, either by players stepping up or by recruiting quality players. Courts has already shown with the majority of his signings that he (and the recruitment team) have an eye for a player. Throughout last season he was able to adapt to losing key players such as Shankland and Fuchs so I'm sure he has plans in place to replace the players leaving this time. Fine tuning the squad and bringing in his own players that suit the way he wants to play is important. Hopefully by doing this then we will be able to perform at a high level again but more attractive on the eye. 


I've no doubt missed lots of other things I could have spoken about but I hope you have enjoyed reading not just this but any of my reviews/blogs. It is always appreciated! I don't plan on doing anymore until the season draws closer! Thank you! 

























Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Kilmarnock Tactical Preview

Hearts v United Tactical Review