Hearts v United Tactical Review
Lineups/setup. United made three changes from the midweek defeat away to Kilmarnock. Out dropped Graham, McGrath (due to injury in the warm up) and Djoum. In came Niskanen, Pawlett and Sibbald. We continued in our usual 343/352 formation with Birighitti in goal, a back three of Edwards on the right, Mulgrew in the middle and McMann on the left. Smith and Niskanen were the wing backs. Levitt and Sibbald were in the midfield with Pawlett playing the link role that McGrath and Harkes has played in recent games. Middleton supported Fletcher up top.

McGrath getting injured in the warm up was a blow but a big opportunity for Pawlett. I expected to see us adopt more of a 343 formation which would drop into a 541 out of possession. I was happy to see Niskanen given a chance from the start. Felt he should have been given more of a chance and with Behich not playing, it was a good opportunity to put him in. I originally wondered if it was maybe a change of shape to a 433 but that would have been a big surprise considering Fox has always preferred the back three formation.
Hearts made two changes from their defeat to Rangers on Wednesday. Out dropped Cochrane and Kuol who were replaced by Halliday and Forrest. Hearts played in a 343 formation with Clark in goal. Hill on the right of the back three with Sibbick in the middle and Rowles on the left. Forrest and Kingsley were the wing backs with Snodgrass and Halliday in the middle of the park. Ginnelly and McKay supporting Shankland up top.
Felt if United were to get anything from the game we needed to deal with the Hearts front three who rotation cleverly and have speed to hurt us.
United Game plan
Forcing Hearts wide
Similar to the Celtic game, our plan was to force Hearts wide then shift across to that side of the pitch to lock them in. United would do this by compacting the centre of the park and forcing Hearts to go wide. Once they go wide then the ball side wing back would look to put pressure on the ball as aggressively as possible. Hearts began to be frustrated by this early on and ended up looking to play high, direct passes forward as they couldn't play through United's shape. This suited United as Mulgrew and Edwards espessilly were able to win the majority of headers against Shankland/Ginnelly or McKay.
Here's an example:
Hearts look to go down their right but Niskanen puts Forrest under pressure and forces the ball backwards. Hearts then switch the play around the back as they can't penetrate through our shape. Rowles has time on the ball but frustratingly goes direct which Mulgrew wins the header easily. United then pick up the 2nd ball and win a foul.
Good United shape, compact with good distances between players. Rowles doesn't want to play the risky pass to penetrate through our shape or play the pass wide as Smith is ready to put pressure on Kingsley once it goes there.
Stopping Snodgrass
Another key element of the United game plan was to not allow Snodgrass time on the ball to dictate the play. Fletcher would often drop onto Snodgrass when Hearts were building the play at the back. This allowed the midfield to remain compact behind the ball.

Here's an example early in the game. Fletcher hardly makes any attempt to put pressure on the ball and solely focuses on Snodgrass to prevent him getting on the ball.
If Fletcher went slightly higher to put pressure on the ball, then Levitt or Sibbald would step up onto Snodgrass to stop him from getting on the ball. In this scenario, it's Levitt who is marking Snodgrass.
That was our off the ball game plan but in possession it was clear we looked to get more players around Fletcher for flick on's or knock downs and to win 2nd balls. Pawlett and Middleton were impressive in the first half due to their energy and creativity in the final 3rd. Niskanen and Smith both provided energy on the wings as well which meant we had better support and options.
One of the moves that showed this was Middletons shot. Although it was given as offside, the link up play and support was very good. Clever runs, first time passes and width all on show. Niskanen and Smith both high up the park providing some sort of width. Middleton, Pawlett and Fletcher showing their intelligence with this link up play.
Early Goal 0-1 United- Fletcher.
United scored from some nice patient play resulting in Fletcher finishing well from a tight angle.
United do well to maintain possession after the original set piece. By the time Sibbald gets on the ball he is looking for the forward pass and holds onto the ball waiting on a run. Niskanen who finds himself in a central position makes a lovely curved run into space behind the Hearts defence and because he is on the move and times the run well, he catches Hill flat footed.
Few things I noticed from this wide angle. Middleton hanging wide attracts Kingsley which opens up a gap between the Hearts defence. If Middleton isn't in that position, Kingsley can narrow up and intercept the Sibbald pass. I've also highlighted Fletcher's position on the far side. You often see Kyogo in these sort of positions. Not interested in the first ball but is in a "cheating position" for the 2nd phase of the attack.

Fletcher is then able to be on the front foot ahead of the Hearts defenders but it's also important that he cuts across them to stop them from intercepting the cross. This could also slow them down allowing Fletcher the advantage. Niskanen also plays the cross quickly first time which doesn't allow the Hearts defence time to get back into position.
United deserved their lead and looked fairly comfortable. The shape was good and Hearts were becoming more and more frustrated as United caused them problems.
The game changed after Edwards was sent off after a VAR check. Looked incredibly harsh but it meant a change of shape. United changed to a 441 formation with Niskanen and Smith dropping into defence as full backs.
The game plan remained the same, Stop Snodgrass from getting on the ball and close off the centre of the pitch. Although Hearts had more possession, United were disciplined and done well to limit Hearts to very little in the remainder of the half.
A key moment just before the break. Neilson making a change of shape to a 4411. This was clever from Hearts as they didn't need the extra defender to deal with one United striker. It meant Forrest and McKay could get higher and wider.
Half time 0-1 United
An excellent first half from United. Disciplined, composed and showed real moments of quality. Only two negatives at half time was the red card which puts us under pressure and the fact we hadn't taken more of our chances we created. Hearts were lacklustre but United were setting traps and forcing errors well.
At half time, Hearts brought on Humphrys for Forest with Ginnelly going into the wide position. It was a clear tactic from Hearts to stretch the play as much as possible to open up the United shape. They looked to make far more switches of play and moved the ball quicker from side to side.
Early on in the 2nd half, Pawlett went off injured and was replaced by Djoum. This meant Sibbald went out to the right hand side of the United midfield with Djoum in the middle with Levitt.
Although United were still disciplined, Hearts were slowly gaining territory and dictating the play more. Snodgrass was becoming a bigger influence as United found it difficult to cover the same ground we were covering with 11 men. McKay started to make an impact and was causing Smith problems down the Hearts left hand side.
Hearts goal 1-1 Shankland
Hearts finally got the goal and it came when a deflected cross was brought down and fired past Birighitti by Shankland
Sibbald almost stops the cross but it still gets into our box. We can't allow Shankland to bring the ball down in the middle of the area. Levitt is too bothered by Humprhys on the edge of the box so he steps to his right away from Shankland and the ball.
Shankland does well to pin Niskanen and create some space for the shot but United need to suffocate the this space. We needed to be up to the ball. Too many standing waiting to see what happens.
Straight after the goal Freeman comes on for Sibbald which was clearly done to try and shore things up and give more defensive protection to Smith up against McKay.
Now United were caught whether to try and get a goal or to protect the point. That's when Hearts countered us.
Hearts goal 2-1 Cochrane
United have the ball in the Hearts half but once we lose possession, Hearts counter quickly. Levitt gets rolled and suddenly we are stretched. We manage to get numbers back but McKay plays a nice pass through to Cochrane who finishes well
Firstly, Levitt should just take the foul right at the start of the move to slow their attack down.
Once McKay gets the ball, it's too easy for him to cut inside and look to link up with his teammates. Humphrys makes a clever run which drags Freeman wide and away from the centre. Cochrane recognises this and sprints into the gap between the United defence.
This gap is big enough for Cochrane to run into and if the pass is right, can get a shot away. Djoum needs to do more to stop the pass but it is a clever pass from McKay. Mulgrew has read the scenario and starts to close the space down.
However, Cochranes positive first touch takes it away from Mulgrew meaning he can't get a block in to prevent the shot on target. Cochrane dispatches well.
Now United are in trouble. After being setup the whole 2nd half to protect a lead, we are now behind and started aimlessly chasing. We started to lose our shape with players jumping out their slots at the wrong times allowing Hearts to penetrate through us more effectively.
Here's an example.
Originally we are still in decent shape but once the ball goes wide, gaps in central areas have opened up and now Snodgrass is behind our midfield playing forward passes.
United got more and more desperate. MacLeod came on for Niskanen as we looked to throw bodies forward in the hope for anything chance.
3-1 Hearts- Humphrys
Of course we could have brought him down before he lets fly but lets be honest, He's hit it very well. Birighitti obviously off his line but just got to give credit to the striker for that one.
Full time Hearts 3-1 United
Disappointing result especially after such a positive first half display. The red card changed the game but the 2nd half became disjointed once Hearts equalised. Sums up United's season really. Capable of playing some good football and competing with the better teams in the league but fragility and vulnerable at the back with no luck going for us whatsoever.
My Man of the Match
Now I'm not claiming he is a world beater but I think ILMARI NISKANEN gives us so much when he plays. His energy and enthusiasm to work hard for the team is what we need more of. He showed he is capable of being more direct and getting at players. I felt he got forward well but done his defensive responsibilities brilliantly as well.
Birighitti was alright again. Certainly have more confidence in him than earlier in the season but unsure if I still fully trust him in general. Makes some decent saves but seems to get beaten easily even if it's not directly his fault. Edwards was doing alright when he was on. Don't think it was a red. Mulgrew had some good defensive moments but then had some clumsy moments as well. He doesn't seem as composed as last season. I thought McMann was good again. I felt he dealt with most things well and put in a good shift for the team. Smith was good in the first half but in the 2nd struggled against McKay. Levitt was decent in the first half. Got on the ball and played some nice passes but the 2nd half just seemed to be too high of a tempo for him. He struggled to get on the ball and the game just went by him. Sibbald worked well. Covered ground as usual. His pass for the Fletcher goal was impressive. Began to tire once moved out into a wider position. Struggled with McKay as well. Felt Pawlett was something we have missed in a while, someone willing to drive forward with the ball. He looked dangerous and had some lovely interplay with Middleton and Fletcher throughout the 1st half. Hopefully the injury isn't too bad. Middleton was very good first half but his role changed in the 2nd so he couldn't be as effective going forward. Fletcher took his goal well and looks so much better when he has support around him. 2nd half he was isolated so his impact became limited.
Djoum got about the park and got stuck in but he couldn't make much of an impact on the ball as we would have liked. Freeman came on to provide Smith some protection against McKay. I can't remember him doing much on the ball. He covered the ground and worked hard but nothing of note in possession. Macleod thrown on for his customary cameo. Feel sorry for him as we seem to always chuck him on when we are desperate.
My Thoughts
This was always a game we knew would be difficult but we showed in the first half display that we can be a good team and cause problems for opponents if we start more on the front foot. Fox seems to have a idea of how to prepare a game plan for teams but if anything changes in the game then we don't seem to be able to adapt. Neilson changed shape once United went to 10 men. He adapted. United never adapted. Yes we went to a back four when Edwards was off but we didn't actually change anything we were doing. Ok, we were ahead and the plan was working in the first half, even with 10 men so we didn't need to change anything at that moment but once the 2nd half started, we needed to find a solution to slow down the Hearts momentum. For me, Freeman or Graham should have been on earlier just to shore things up again. Hearts were going down the wings a lot while looking to put crosses into the box. The extra defender could help deal with the crosses or to double up better on the Hearts wide players.
Once we went behind, I think the attacking players on the bench such as Anaku/Macleod or Cudjoe should have been on earlier to try and be more attacking. Still aware of their defensive responsibilities but with a freedom going forward to be direct and make things happen. Hearts had that throughout their team. Ginnelly, Kuol, McKay, Humprhys, Forrest all have trickery and pace to hurt the opposition. We didn't utilise our bench enough to freshen things up in an attacking sense. Yes it was difficult because we were down to 10 men but we appeared to just think keeping doing the same thing will get us back in the game.
A disappointing week with no points collected. The cup gives us a rest bite but we really do need to start winning games again or we will be in big big trouble!
As always thank you for reading this review, I hope you have enjoyed it.
Comments
Post a Comment