Hibs v Dundee United Review
Hibs v Dundee United Review- REDUCED
Didn't watch the game and haven't been able to watch the game back fully so here's my review of the goals.
Lineups/Setup
United only made one change from their defeat to Rangers last week. Djoum came in for Levitt in midfield. We stayed in our usual 343/352 formation with Birighitti in goal, a back three of Smith and McMann flanking Edwards in the middle. Behich and Freeman were wing backs with Djoum joining Sibbald in the centre of the park. Harkes and Middleton supported Fletcher up top.
Levitt missing was a slight blow but Djoum is capable of doing a job if he has help around him. Thought Fox might have brought Graham or Mulgrew into the back three to freshen it up but I would expect one or both of those to come in against Livingston midweek. Happy enough with this lineup. McGrath is just back from an injury so didn't expect to see him come straight back into the starting lineup but was good to see him on the bench.
Hibs made one change from their 3-2 win against Motherwell last week. Cadden dropped out to be replaced by Fish. However there was a rejig of the lineup from last week. They played in a 433 formation with Marshall in goal, A back four of Campbell, Fish, Bushiri and Stevenson. Porteous sat infront of the defence with Magennis and Newell a head of him. Youan and McGeady provided the width with the lone striker of Nisbet up top.
Admittedly not watched lots of Hibs this season but their side looked unbalanced and awkward to me. Campbell playing right back when he is usually played in midfield seemed like an area to target for United. Porteous being asked to play the sitting role when he is their best defender seemed counter-productive. Their front three looked dangerous but felt United could get at their defence.
Early United goal- Middleton
Lots of good aspects from United here for this goal. Firstly, it's good to see United actually creating a chance from a throw-in. It's been a pet hate of mine for a while now that United don't seem to be great at keeping possession from our own throw-ins especially in the opposition half so it's great to see us score from one.
Our setup from the throw in is interesting. With Hibs marking man for man to the players nearest to Freeman, it would take some movement from United to create space/free themselves from the marking setup of Hibs.
Harkes position of being really high and wide drags Stevenson wider, creating a greater distance between him and his left centre half Bushiri. Sibbald and Djoum are closely marked by the Hibs midfield so it would take some movement to free themselves. Middleton's position is interesting as it occupies Porteous. This prevents Porteous from covering any space in front of the defence. Middleton is on the back shoulder of Porteous meaning it's difficult for the Hibs player to see him and the ball at the same time. Fletcher also playing a part by occupying Bushiri.
Good rotational movement from Sibbald and Djoum catch out Hibs who don't switch on to the movement. Djoum is now running into the box and at the Hibs defence. Middleton has now ran off the back of Porteous who hasn't given any protection to the Hibs defence.
A clever touch from Fletcher allows the ball to fall to Middleton who does really well to control and finish nicely. Good supporting runs from United here.
Hibs goal 1-1 Nisbet
No pressure on Porteous, who has dropped deep to get on the ball but our shape is alright here. The back 5 could be in a straighter line but in general it's alright. The lines are compact and Hibs don't have many central passes on which is forcing them wider.
Porteous plays a good switch to Campbell, who has advanced on the Hibs right hand side. Behich could maybe engage Campbell so he isn't able to bring the ball down and find a pass/cross but that's being slightly harsh on Behich. The problem is in the middle. Djoum and Sibbald are slow to react to the ball played over their heads and can't get back into a good defensive position until it's too late. The space between the United defence and midfield has increased greatly.
Nisbet hangs back outside the box making him difficult to pick up. With Sibbald and Djoum too high up the park, they can't protect this space. McMann is looking to support Behich/protect the front post if any crosses coming into the box. Edwards is looking to prepare for any crosses as well. Neither McMann or Edwards pick up Nisbet.
Nisbet has plenty of space to receive the ball and manipulate the ball to where he wants to go. He does well to work it onto his right foot and fire home for Hibs but it's too easy from a United point of view. No one recognising that Nisbet is the main danger and should be picked up. Marking space rather than the player. The space won't score the goal but the player will.
2-1 United- Harkes
High ball played up to Fletcher is good as it gives him something to work with. With United also having players making runs off Fletcher, it means he can link the play easier. Freeman finds himself infield with Harkes out wide. This has created a 2v1 on Stevenson. After Fletcher wins the header, Freeman does really well to flick it on to Harkes out wide.
It's good to see Harkes being positive on the ball by driving forward. Head down and direct. We also have some good supporting runs from Freeman and Middleton. Fletcher is taken out off the ball which takes away one of our options but still the support is there.
Late equaliser 2-2 Nisbet
The defensive line isn't great here. Smith, although is closely marking Nisbet is deeper than the left side of our defence. Freeman as well is slightly deeper.
Nisbet should never get the opportunity to bring the ball down in our box. Smith is close to him but it's still too easy for Nisbet to pin him and control the ball. Can Edwards maybe double press Nisbet here to suffocate the space he has to work in?
Thoughts
As I haven't watched the game back and wasn't at the game, I'm limited to how the game went from a tactical point of view. Going from what I heard/seen from highlights. United were desperately unlucky not to get the three points. To be 2-1 up with a few minutes to go, it's disappointing not to see the game out and get the win which would have been crucial. Most would have taken a draw at the start of the game but the manner in which we conceded the late goal makes it feel more like a defeat than a draw. Similar to the Hearts game a few weeks ago. We need to find a way to hold on to these results.
As much as people maybe don't think we have, we have improved. Our performances are better refined and organised. We have a better shape to us which means we are less disjointed. The results since the return has shown this.
We do however have some glaring issues which need resolved. We continue to give away sloppy goals. Nisbet is a quality striker but he was given too much time for both goals. Defensive reinforcements are a must. We have ok cover in the defensive positions but we lack real natural options at centre back and have resorted to playing full backs in there due to lack of mobility. Protection in front of the midfield is still something we lack. Djoum/Sibbald/Levitt have worked well to a point but we lack an enforcer and someone who will protect the defence effectively and more importantly wants to do this job for the team. Getting these two positions in the door this month could go a long way of keeping us out of the danger zone and can help us "lock down" games when holding onto a lead.
Judging substitutions are very much a hindsight thing however our use of subbies has been poor. That's a couple of games where we have been crying out for changes to freshen things up as some players are running on empty. So either Fox doesn't trust some of the players on the bench or he just doesn't like changing things. Either way it needs sorted. Players like Meekison, Niskanen, and Cudjoe haven't been given any proper chance under Fox but yet can be useful. I'm not saying these guys are the answer to all our problems but we should use them when required. Niskanen for example yesterday could have been used as a pacey runner up top to hassle the Hibs defence for the last 10/15mins once Middleton had ran his course. Meekison could have freshen things up in the middle etc.
We are not far away from getting ourselves out of trouble but we need to keep working and not take anything for granted. As much as the form since break has been decent. We have a tough few weeks coming up and it could all going badly wrong if we don't keep pushing forward.
















Comments
Post a Comment