Dundee United v Rangers Review

Dundee United v Rangers Review

United v Rangers

Lineups/setups

United made one change from the win at McDiarmid with Fletcher returning to the line up in replace of Watt. United continued in our 343 formation with Birighitti in goal, a back three of Smith and McMann on the sides of Edwards. Freeman as right wing back and Behich on the left. Sibbald and Levitt were the two centre midfielders with Harkes and Middleton supporting Fletcher up top. 

United

Not surprises with the line up. Most would have expected Fletcher to return to the starting line up even if it was slightly harsh on Watt. Felt it was another case of setting up with mobility in the back three to combat Kent and Sakala. 

Rangers made three changes from their draw from their last outing v Celtic. McLaughlin, Jack and Colak replaced McGregor, Kamara and Morelos. They played in a 4231 formation with McLaughlin in goal, a back four of Barisic and Tavernier as full backs with Davies and Goldson at centre defence. Jack and Lundstram were deeper to allow Tillman to play more advanced as a no.10. Kent played off the left with Sakala on the right. Colak was the lone striker. 

Rangers

United Containing

The game plan was clear from United- Contain Rangers. This tactic would mean United would sacrifice possession and look to maintain a solid shape behind the ball to limit the space for Rangers to play in within the United half. 

shape

541

It would often become a 541 formation with Harkes and Middleton becoming wide midfielders at the sides of Levitt and Sibbald. Both were tasked with dealing with the Rangers full backs when they came forward. The purpose of the shape was to force Rangers wide and not through our shape. 

Half space control. 

When Rangers were building the play, their width is usual provided by their full backs with their wide players given the freedom to drift inside and pick up positions in the half spaces. The positioning of Harkes and Middleton meant United were able to limit Rangers playing into these half space areas and force them wide to Barisic or Tavernier. 

Here's an example. If Rangers have the ball at the back. Harkes would look to do two jobs. Prevent a pass through to Kent and also to be able to put pressure on Barisic if the ball went wide. Freeman could also put pressure on Barisic as well if it was deeper into the United half. 
Half space
More often than not though, Freeman would hold his position to protect Smith against Kent by limiting the space for Kent to run into. Harkes would work back to still prevent any passes into Kent and look to force Barisic backwards. 
Half space

United worked hard to keep maintain this type of control and in the first half it worked. However it did have a down side. It meant we didn't engage higher up the park as we could have which often allowed Davies and Goldson time to pick passes. When we won possession, it would leave big distances to cover to counter quickly (not impossible as Smith's chance shows) but it would be tough work to cover than ground quickly. It also would mean Freeman and Behich weren't as aggressive going forward or engaging higher up the park. 

Rangers looked to work their rotations to try and open United up with the likes of Jack and Lundstram dropping into false full back positions to allow Tillman/Kent/Sakala more freedom to roam infield. Both Rangers full backs in the first half weren't positioned as high so their movement lacked conviction which meant they resorted to passes that didn't come off or would keep circulating the ball by usually going backwards which suited United. 

United chances 

United had a couple of opportunities in the first half which came from well worked moves that caused problems for the Rangers defence. 

Middleton dangerous cross 

After Rangers half cleared a United corner, United worked a nice move down the left hand side resulting in a dangerous cross from Middleton being fired across the 6yard box


United in a good position here as they outnumber Rangers 5v4 in this area of the pitch. Good supporting angles and options for Smith on the ball opens up a quick passing move. 
Middleton

McMann plays a quick pass to Behich who then plays a clever ball behind Tavernier into the space for Middleton who has recognised where the space is. United still have good numbers in the box from the corner so plenty of targets to aim for. 
Middleton

Middleton has time to put quality in the box so now it depends on the runs from the United players in the box. 
Middleton

Fletcher is in a good position right at the back post. Edwards is looking to get front post with Harkes looking for the cut back option. Can Levitt gamble more at the back post? 
Middleton

Middleton puts a good ball across the goal with both Edwards and Fletcher in dangerous positions and if McLaughlin doesn't get a touch on the ball, one of them surely scores. If I'm being critical, could Edwards got across the front to get ahead of McLaughlin? I also think if Levitt gambled at the back post, he could have had a chance to score himself. 
Middleton

Smith Chance


United were able to win possession after forcing Rangers wide and getting players on that side of the pitch. A mistake by Colak is pounced on by Smith. 
Smith

Harkes quickly reacts and attacks the space left by Jack, who has rotated into the false full back position mentioned previously. Smith does well to play the pass into the space under some pressure from recovering Rangers players. 
Smith

Once Harkes gets the ball, Rangers are stretched and unbalanced. Three Rangers players have been drawn to ball leaving space to be attacked. I think Fletcher should be more decisive with his run. 

Fletcher could pull wider to try and drag Goldson slightly wider to open space centrally for Smith to attack. This ends up happening but I think Fletcher could have exaggerate this movement to open up the space more. 
Smith

Or he could have darted across the front of Goldson which would have opened up a pass from Harkes in behind Davies and possibly an opportunity to run through on goal on the angle if timed correctly. This could have dragged Goldson across and opened up space for Smith at the back rather than in the middle. 
Smith

Smith does well to get onto the pass and the space opens up for him to get the shot away. He should do better with the chance and at least make McLaughlin work. Surprised to see Fletcher not involved at all once Smith gets the ball. 
Smith chance

It was a big opportunity for United which was still well worked even if I'm suggesting areas in which it could have worked differently. 

Half time United 0-0 Rangers

A decent half from United. Shape is working well and Rangers were limitted to very little. The best chances of the half came United's way and if a bit of luck/composure, we could have went in ahead. Rangers not really at the races. 

Rangers started the second half with intent! They moved the ball quicker, their tempo was higher and United struggled to cope with their movement. Barisic and Tavernier were far more aggressive in their positioning providing that width, which allowed Kent, Tillman and Sakala to roam more freely than in the first half. Morelos was now on for Colak which posed a different challenge. He was always looking to be on the shoulder of United defenders which gave them more of a threat in behind. 

This forced United deeper. The United defence would find themselves on the edge of their own box with the midfield camped in front of it. This allowed Rangers to push players higher and basically created a 5v5 scenario. 

Deep

1-0 Rangers- Sakala 

Rangers got the opener thanks to a well worked move from their point of view. A few quick passes allows Sakala the chance who powerfully fires past Birighitti. 


The move starts after Harkes engages with Davies. Nothing wrong with this but it the rest of the team didn't seem prepared for this step to engage. Harkes failed to prevent the pass into the half space so Davies is able to play into the feet of Sakala. 
Sakala goal

Although Smith is tight with Sakala, he is now dragged away from his defensive slot. The reason I don't think this step from Harkes in the first photo wasn't planned is Freeman's position here. His deeper position here is as if the ball had been played wide from Davies original pass. I think if Freeman was prepared for the step up by Harkes his position would be closer to Barisic. Jack and Sibbald are highlighted here as well. Jack recognises the space in behind Smith and makes a clever run into it. 
Sakala goal

No pressure on Barisic allows him to play a nice ball down the line to Jack who is matched by Sibbald but not enough to prevent Jack progressing the play. Again Sakala recognises the space in behind Sibbald and sprints into it. Edwards is pinned centrally by Morelos preventing him from reading the ball through earlier. 
Sakala goal

With Edwards pinned back, he is slower to react to Sakala getting onto the ball. Smith doesn't track the run either which doesn't help. Birighitti seemed to have closed the angle down well but is taken by the quickness of the strike and can't react. 
Sakala goal

2-0 Rangers- Tillman 

Rangers got their 2nd a few minutes later after poor play from United gave away possession cheaply and Rangers punished us for it. 

McMann gives away the ball when attempting the switch of play. Poor but United still had plenty of numbers back. United slightly disjointed on our left hand side here with Middleton chasing back with Tavernier here after Behich making a run forward. 
Tillman goal

Tavernier is able to waltz into the United box with no challenge. Passive from United here. Again plenty of numbers back. 
Tillman goal

Birighitti makes a good save but the ball breaks out to Tillman who finishes well through a crowded box. However, United get four players out to the ball but none manage to get a block in. Disappointing. 
Tillman goal

After these two goals, United changed to a 352 with Harkes going back into midfield with Middleton stepping up as a striker alongside Fletcher. The game took a lull as Rangers kept possession without ever looking to increase their lead. United struggled to keep any sort of possession. 

Full time United 0-2 Rangers

Disappointing after a decent first half that the game petered out. The two early 2nd half goals killed the game and Rangers looked content with that and were comfortable enough. United's heads dropped and didn't show a great deal or ever look like getting back into the game. 

My man of the match. 

Mark Birighitti gets it for me this time. Felt we made some good saves esp in the 2nd half. There were a few shots from Rangers that were straight at him but he dealt with everything fairly well. 1st goal, I felt his reaction wasn't great but that was a powerful close range shot so I'll cut him some slack. Amazing what a few clean sheets and confidence can do. 

Smith stuck to his task in the first half fairly well but 2nd half I felt he struggled with their upped intensity and tempo. He should have done better with his chance at the end of the first half. Edwards looked more comfortable playing against Colak than he did with Morelos in the 2nd half. Colak looked to want to get into a physical battle with Edwards which suited him however, Morelos was playing off his shoulder and looking for little runs in behind which caused Edwards problems. McMann was similar to Smith. Looked solid first half but then struggled with their movement and intensity. All of the back three lacked composure and confidence in possession, not helped by lack of options ahead of them. Freeman sadly wasn't at his best. Clearly had been told to hold his position more to protect Smith which is fair enough but he wasn't able to get forward as much and then he delayed in playing passes too often in possession. Behich was similar. Some good runs forward at times but seemed restrained. Levitt showed some nice touches/passes in first half but fell right out the game. Looked to be struggling with the tempo of the game and was very passive out of possession. It wasn't Sibbald's best game. He worked hard and cover lots of ground but he looked leggy as the game wore on. Harkes was decent first half. His positioning out of possession was sometimes off but in possession he drove forward a few times and had some nice moments. Like most, he fell right out the game and struggled badly to provide any composure. Middleton was dangerous in the first half. Worked hard and put himself about but game passed him by in the 2nd half. Fletcher was a nuisance for the Rangers defence. Won his headers and had a few opportunities that he could have done better with but was a decent enough performance from him. 

Djoum came on for Sibbald. Covered ground and made a few challenges but didn't do anything to impact the game. MacLeod ran about and looked interested. Hard to judge a player when he doesn't get much time on the ball and spends most of the time on the park chasing Rangers players. Watt looked uninterested. Brutally honest, he looked in a huff. Meekison came on right at the end which seemed like a waste of time for everyone.

My Thoughts.....

I was happy enough with the first half. We done a good containing job on them with the best chances falling for us whenever we broke forward. Our shape was alright, the distances were good and we limited Rangers to very little. The only criticism I had was I would have liked to have seen United be slightly more aggressive and get after them but I could understand the tactical decision to contain. Our play in possession could have been better in the first half as well as too often we would resort to going long to Fletcher or in behind when we didn't have the runners or support but we did have decent spells of play and overall the first half was alright. 

2nd half I felt was far too passive. Everyone knew Rangers would come out quick in the 2nd half after a lethargic first half display from them so United needed to be on guard but we seemed to drop deeper and allowed Rangers time and space to build into their rhythm. Yes Rangers upped their urgency on the ball but United were too standoffish. Rangers done well to exploit United during this phase but the goals were too easy. We didn't even look to try and get back in the game. We looked to have "settled" for the 2-0. We are still in a relegation battle so I can understand the point of not wanting to put a dent on the goal difference by chasing the game and possibly getting caught in the process but surely we needed to try and get back in the game some way or another. Disappointing 

Felt the substitutions were wrong. Felt we were crying out for energy and natural enthusiasm to run and hassle Rangers. Felt someone like Meekison could have provided that in the midfield. Even the likes of Niskanen or Anaku would have been decent options in regards to getting players on the park who could cover the ground and be more direct when attacking. The substitutions we done were like for like which didn't really impact the game or change the way we were playing. If anything we fell more out the game once these were made. Although he was tiring, Middleton was our only real out ball. We then took off our only physical presence in Fletcher. We weren't doing much going forward before these subs but I don't think they were what were required at the time. All in hindsight I suppose. 

Frustrating but we move on. Next up is Hibs at Easter Road. They are very hit or miss so this could be any result. Need to get back to winning ways if we are to get ourselves away from any relegation worries. 

United v Rangers

I hope you have enjoyed reading this review and as always thank you! 







Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Kilmarnock Tactical Preview

Tactical Review of United 21/22

Hearts v United Tactical Review