Celtic v United Tactical Review

 Celtic v United Tactical Review 

Celtic v United

Lineups/Setup

United made two changes from last week's defeat to Motherwell. In came Djoum and Harkes for Watt and Levitt. We played in a 352 formation with Birighitti continued in goal, Smith and McMann flanking Edwards in the back three. Behich and Freeman were the wing backs again. Djoum would be the deeper of the three  with Sibbald and Harkes slightly higher. McGrath looked to support Fletcher up top. 

United team

Celtic made seven changes from their midweek Champions League defeat to Real Madrid. Out dropped Starfelt, Juranovic, Taylor, Mooy, Kyogo, Abada and Maeda with Ralston, Carter-Vickers, Bernabei, Turnbull, Haksabanovic, Giakoumakis and Jota replacing them. They played in their usual 433 formation with Hart in goal, a back four of Ralston, Carter-Vickers, Jenz and Bernabei. O'Riley the deeper midfielder with Turnbull and Hatate advanced. Jota was on the left with Haksabanovic on the right. Giakoumakis was the lone striker. 

Celtic team

No real surprises in the lineup. Harkes coming back to provide the energy to cover ground was expected. Levitt dropping out was a slight surprise but given Fox's comments in the media and the fact he got hooked at half time last week suggested we should have expected it. 

Midfield setup

One of the interesting tactical decisions I was looking at was the setup in midfield or more importantly, the positioning of McGrath out of possession. I originally thought that McGrath would play narrow on the left hand side of a midfield four with Harkes having a similar role on the right hand side. 
However, he was played almost as a second striker alongside Fletcher. Out of possession, United were almost happy to allow the Celtic centre backs time on the ball but preventing easy passes into the midfield. McGrath and Fletcher's job would be to drop onto the deepest Celtic midfielder. This was done to prevent central passes through our shape and to force Celtic into wider positions to then shift across and press. 
Midfield shape
Midfield shape

This allowed Harkes or Sibbald to step out into the wide areas to press the Celtic full backs or any of the Celtic midfielders who rotated into these areas. It required Djoum and the far side centre midfielder to cover across the pitch to protect the pressing player.
Midfield shape
Midfield shape

It was a brave decision by Fox to keep McGrath advanced and look to leave two up against Celtic but it did leave lots of ground to cover for Harkes, Djoum and Sibbald which left space which Celtic were able to exploit. 

1-0 Celtic- Haksabanovic

Celtic exploited this ground that the side United midfielders had to cover to get a cross into the box which United half clear. Then Celtic win the ball back quickly and get in behind us for an simple finish for Haksabanovic. 

Celtic move the ball around quickly and make Sibbald and Harkes run endlessly to open up some space for Ralston. By the time Ralston has time and space on the ball, our midfield is in a poor shape with Djoum very deep, Harkes and Sibbald next to each other neither able to get out to Ralston due to the running they've had to do. Behich can't step up as Haksabanovic has pinned him back. McMann is spare but is too far away to step up and press the ball either. Because of this, United have no option but to allow Ralston to cross into the danger area. 
Celtic first goal

United actually clear the ball well enough and as the ball goes up to Fletcher, Harkes and McGrath are looking to support beyond the ball. Fletcher needs to play the ball quickly as he is under pressure from behind. 
Celtic first goal

However, Fletcher takes too many touches and is swamped by Celtic players. He isn't helped with safe passing options but Celtic have pressed him quickly. Now Harkes and McGrath are both out the play as Celtic gain possession in the middle of our half. 
Celtic first goal

Once Hatate has the ball, Freeman is caught wrong side of Jota due to trying get forward and provide a passing option out wide when Fletcher had possession. Smith however needs to be a step over to his right hand side. He doesn't need to be so narrow as Giakoumakis can be marked by Edwards. The main danger is the penetrative pass between Freeman and Smith. 
Celtic first goal

Smith is almost able to intercept the pass from this position anyway but if he was a step to his right then there's a good chance he stops the pass through to Jota. Once in behind, United are hoping Jota messes up the pass/shot. Haksabanovic is already getting into position for the back post finish if Jota passes. McMann is too late to react to it and is unable to prevent it. Question marks over Birighitti positioning as he seems too far out and over too his right. 
Celtic first goal

Celtic cut us open easily after winning possession back. Lack of defensive reactions is a worry. It's a carbon copy of the majority of goals Celtic scored against us at Tannadice. Slow to react and not tracking runners quickly enough. 

United Equaliser 1-1 Fletcher Penalty

United managed to quickly get themselves back level thanks to a VAR decision resulting in a penalty being given which Fletcher put away. 

From the original free kick, United clearly looked to exploit the back post with McMann and Edwards targeting Turnbull and O'Riley at the back of the pack. Djoum behind Carter-Vickers prevents him from dominating the aerial ball. The ball from McGrath is decent and takes out the dominant Celtic defenders from attacking the ball. 
Penalty

McMann is able to keep the attack alive and puts in a good ball back into the middle of the Celtic box. United are outnumbered with the bodies in the box but the quality of the ball back in allows Edwards and Fletcher attack it. Fletcher gets good connection which is blocked by Bernabei.  
Penalty

Quality of deliveries and having players attack it with intent causes problems. 

Personally I don't think it should have been a penalty. By the letter of the law it is but I don't agree with that law. I don't think the defender could do anything about it. 

Anyway, Fletcher scores to bring us level. Not the cleanest of penalties but as long as they go in, that's all that matters. 

Our Achilles Heel- Not Stopping Crosses! 

A issue United have had for a while now has been preventing crosses coming into our box. Celtic had 36 crosses into our box (a few were corner kicks). Allowing this many into the box will always cause problems. 
Crosses
If we were strong at dealing with these crosses then we could be slightly more forgiven for the number of crosses coming into our box but that's the thing, we are poor at dealing with these crosses. In our last six games before this one (including Killie in the cup), we had conceded ten goals, 5 of those have come from crosses into our box. 
That isn't including Ross County's goal, St Johnstone's 2nd goal and Rangers first goal. Those wouldn't be classed as generic crosses into our box but they were balls played into our box along the ground. 
It's a massive problem!

Celtic exploited this on a number of occasions. 

In this example, Freeman doesn't do enough to prevent the cross from Jota. Giakoumakis is aggressive in the middle while McMann loses flight of the ball. Birighitti makes a decent save but it's still far too easy not only for the cross but for a free header in the middle of our box. 

Too much space between players in the box. Gaps easily exploited. No one plugging the gaps. The positions McMann and Behich get themselves into here is poor. McMann needs to be the other side of Giakoumakis but instead is wrong side. 
Crosses

Here's an example from the 2nd half. Jota's trickery makes him difficult to stop but he is still allowed too much time to dig out a cross. Turnbull this time is able to get a header in the middle of the goal. McMann again not doing great here by not even challenging properly. A combination of Behich and Birighitti prevents a goal. 

Smith and Freeman basically both doing the same thing which means no one is covering the front post area. McMann this time is in a better position as he is closer to Edwards but he doesn't attempt to challenge for the ball and instead looks to put Turnbull off but that doesn't work. Two Celtic players at the back post in dangerous positions. 
Crosses

Final example again from the 2nd half. Abada is able to get a cross into our box far too easily again. Kyogo (one of the smallest players on the park) able to get a free header again in our box. 

In this one, our positioning is better at the back post but the defence is just too static with no one attacking the ball. Kyogo is always on the move and reacts better to the ball coming into the box than the United defence. 
Crosses

This was shown as well by the Celtic 2nd goal. 

2-1 Celtic- Haksabanovic second goal 

Celtic went ahead again after United partially cleared their lines from a corner. O'Riley floats a nice ball back into the area which finds it's way to Haksabanovic who fires Celtic back in front. 


O'Riley has too much time to put a quality ball back into the United box. The United defensive line is all over the place. Edwards and Smith are both deeper than the rest of the team. Disjointed. Also worth looking at the body shape of all the players. Majority of the Celtic players look proactive with players already on the move looking for anything breaking in the box. While the United players look static and flat footed. 
2nd goal

Birighitti needs to do better. The shot isn't in the corner, it's fairly central and he needs to have a stronger wrist to save that. He also appears to try and parry it rather than hold. I don't know why he is using this technique when the shot isn't in the corner. Poor 
2nd goal

Half time Celtic 2-1 United

A poor opening from United and when Celtic took the lead, we all feared the worst however we grew into the half and managed to get ourselves level fairly quickly. Although Celtic had a few chances, we were being awkward but the 2nd goal was again a poor goal to concede and allowed Celtic to go in at half time ahead. 

United's shape was unchanged. We kept working hard to prevent any central passes and for the first twenty minutes or so of the 2nd half, we were holding Celtic out. They did have chances as expected (the Turnbull and Forrest chances) but in general our shape was making it difficult for Celtic to cut through us. 

Fox then made some chances. On came Levitt, Middleton, Meekison and Watt in the same of about ten minutes. This gave United some much needed energy and, in the case of Levitt, Quality on the ball. 

Middleton then had a massive chance from a lovely pass from Levitt. United play a quick, short free kick and Levitt plays a great pass through the gap for Middleton who is through on goal. He does well to get it past Hart but Taylor is on the line to stop the goal. 

There are a few things I like and don't like about this. 

Levitt's pass is brilliant but it doesn't happen unless Middleton makes the run. Taking a quick free kick to catch teams out is something we very rarely do so it's nice that it caused a problem. 

Middleton chance

If Middleton's first touch is better then he maybe opens the goal up better but he still does well enough to get a decent shot away. However, the lack of reaction from any United player is disappointing. The reactions of the Celtic defenders is good and they get their reward by clearing it off the line. If United's attacking players had shown the same level of reactions, we might have had a tap in. 
Middleton chance

United then hit the bar from the resulting corner. The substitutes had made an impact and suddenly we were keeping possession better and looked a better team. Celtic still looked dangerous when they had the ball but United were definitely growing in confidence. 

2-2 Levitt Goal 

United got level thanks to a cross from Levitt that went past everyone and into the far corner. 


Levitt showing composure and awareness to turn when he had time and space on the ball. He looks to pick out Watt who has made a good run across his defender. Although the ball goes over Watt, it's a good ball to put in as Hart has to react late incase Watt gets a touch on it. 

Celtic goal 3-2 Kyogo 

As soon as United scored the equaliser, Celtic pilled on the pressure and upped the tempo again. They managed to force a few corners and Kyogo found himself free 6 yards out to nod home. 

Kyogo makes his run from the edge of the box but neither of Middleton or Meekison pick him up. Both point and pass him onto the other one. Neither take the responsibility and just mark him. The space in the middle of the goal is unoccupied. Any of the spare players available should have just plugged this gap to prevent free runs into that area. 
Celtic 3rd goal
Celtic 3rd goal

Ralston wins the flick on at the front post ahead of Watt. Big gap between players in the box allows Kyogo a free header. Birighitti possibly too far over to his near post? 
Celtic 3rd goal


4-2 Abada 

Celtic rubbed salt into the wounds by scoring again to make it 4-2. Abada runs through and finishes nicely past Birighitti. 

As United are clearly throwing bodies forward to get a late equaliser again, it's left a 2v2 down our left hand side. Abada and Maeda are quick and their pace gets themselves in behind. McMann doesn't track the run of Abada. 

Full time Celtic 4-2 United 

Scoreline slightly harsh on United. Celtic dominated the play as expected and missed a few decent chances but United kept battling away and done well to get themselves level. Felt Celtic were fairly lacklustre esp in the 2nd half. They didn't need to get out of 2nd gear but once United started to gain confidence and then get the equaliser, Celtic then clicked into gear again and realised they needed to up the tempo again. They then exposed United's vulnerabilities. Poor marking from a corner in the last minute is criminal. The fourth goal just is typical Celtic and makes the scoreline more favourable for them. 

My Man of the Match. 

Dylan Levitt in his 2nd half cameo made such a big impact on the game from a United point of view. He brought quality in possession and composure which we lacked before he came on. We looked far more dangerous once he was on the park. 

Birighitti made some decent saves but he needs to do better with the 2nd goal. His positioning seems off and communication with his defence seems to be an issue. Smith worked away but struggled with their movement. Edwards dealt with Giakoumakis well enough but struggled with mobility when balls played down the side. McMann was poor I thought. Teams are clearly targeting the back post and he struggles to cover that area. Freeman worked away but struggled against Jota. His trickery is just a bit too much for him. Behich done ok. Needs protection in front of him at times. Djoum had a few decent moments but his lack of mobility didn't help. Harkes covered plenty of ground but no real quality on the ball when needed. Sibbald was similar to Harkes. McGrath was alright. Some nice touches and link up with Fletcher but couldn't get into the game enough. Fletcher held the ball up ok but lacked support. Good for him to get another goal. 

Meekison was good when he came on. Showed bravery on the ball and provided energy in the middle. Middleton made some good runs and was unlucky not to score. Watt never really done a great deal when he was on but his run for the goal was important. 

Thoughts 

Punished for mistakes. We continue to fail to do the basics when defending and until we rectify these mistakes, we won't get ourselves out the trouble we are in. Performance at Parkhead was ok. Disjointed at times but also had a small spell in each half where we looked like a decent team but when we can't do the basics, we are always fighting a losing battle. 
Getting back level so late on was a test to see who could step up and take the responsibility to say "we're not conceding" If we held on it would have been a massive psychological boost for the team but instead we fell into the same bad habits of not doing the basics! 
The Kilmarnock game now becomes huge! It's a must win in my opinion! It's an opportunity to show we have the battling qualities to drag ourselves out of it! 
United v celtic

Thanks very much for reading! Hope you have enjoyed! 






















Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Kilmarnock Tactical Preview

Tactical Review of United 21/22

Hearts v United Tactical Review