Aberdeen v United Tactical Review
Aberdeen v Dundee United Tactical Review
Lineups/Setup
United made one change from our midweek win against Kilmarnock. Sibbald came in for Djoum in midfield. This meant we stayed in the 343 formation we resorted to against Killie. Birighitti continued in goal with a back three of Smith, Edwards and Graham. Behich and Freeman were the wing backs. Levitt and the returning Sibbald were in the centre of midfield. Middleton and McGrath supporting the lone striker Fletcher up top.
Aberdeen made two changes from midweek defeat away to Livingston. Richardson and MacKenzie dropped out to be replaced by Kennedy and Coulson. They set up in a 352 formation with Roos in goal, A back three of McCrorie on the right, Stewart in the middle with Scales on the left. Kennedy and Coulson were the wing backs. Ramadani would sit in the midfield and allow Barron and Clarkson get more advanced. Miovski and Duk were the striker partnership up top.
United shape off the ball
Similar to the Kilmarnock game, the change to a 343 rather than a 352 has given United much better shape off the ball. It has also gave some much needed support to the wing backs who have been often outnumbered recently before this tactical change.
When Aberdeen had possession at the back, McGrath and Middleton had dual jobs. If they can engage with McCrorie (RCB) or Scales (LCB) then they would attempt to put pressure on. This was the trigger for that side wing back to engage with the Aberdeen wing back. Fletcher would look to prevent penetration through the middle into Ramadani. Levitt and Sibbald would look to get up and engage Barron or Clarkson if they dropped in to help when Aberdeen were building up.
Here's a freeze frame of this. Middleton and McGrath on the Aberdeen centre backs preventing easy passes out. Levitt and Sibbald are backing up the press by being in a position to step and pressurise the deep Aberdeen midfielders.
However, if our wing backs weren't able to get higher to engage with their Aberdeen counterpart then it was McGrath and Middleton's job to drop back in and create the 541 formation. This prevented the Aberdeen wing backs from progressing the play in the wide areas but it did mean United would often let the Aberdeen centre backs time on the ball. Fletcher in these scenarios would drop right onto Ramadani and allow Stewart, McCrorie and Scales possession.
This provided defensive protection but meant we couldn't engage the ball enough. At times this did make Aberdeen try and force passes through our shape or over the top which came to nothing but United did need to engage higher to force the issue from an attacking point of view.
Lots of midfield battles and turnovers for the majority of the first half. Neither team had much quality on the ball. Both teams were keeping the ball well but not really progressing up the park and the play would often break down in the final third.
Aberdeen Penalty
United conceded a penalty when Duk ran through on goal and was brought down by Birighitti. This could have been easily avoided by better positioning or "game intelligence"
Levitt plays a pass into Middleton, who has some space to work in but looks to play first time into Fletcher's feet (I assume that's who he was aiming for) but he doesn't connect well enough with the pass. Not against the idea but with the time he had, he probably could have taken a touch and fired a shot.
Our midfield positioning here isn't great as both Levitt and Sibbald are over on one side of the park. I know they were both helping keep possession but one needs to hold slightly to protect in case of a turnover.
Miovski is able to get the ball under control and drive forward. Duk is supporting on his left, exploiting the gap between Smith and Edwards. Although Smith has recovering well, Duk is quickier and another reason why Smith should have held his position in the first place. Sibbald is on the wrong side and isn't able to get a clean challenge on the ball. Probably should just take one for the team and bring Miovski down to prevent the counter.
Graham's body position when he makes the challenge isn't great. Flat footed and easy for Miovski to get a little touch past him. Graham should have just adjusted his body and ran with Miovski or just bring him down.
Once Miovski is past Graham, Edwards is originally unsure on whether to go to the ball or cover the Duk run but his positioning is ok. With Sibbald and Graham hunting down Miovski, Edwards just needs stay in a position to cover Miovski if he gets to the edge of the box or if the ball goes to Duk.
Birighitti then comes out and challenges for the ball. He doesn't need to come that far out. He just needs to close the angle and make himself bigger. By coming out, it gives Duk the opportunity to nick the ball past him. Also gives the ref a decision to make.
Miovski puts away the penalty well.
Half time- Aberdeen 1-0 United
Bit of a nothing half of football. Aberdeen with the majority of possession but not doing much with it. United's shape off the ball was containing Aberdeen well but had no real threat going forward.
The start of the 2nd half continued similar to the 1st half. Not a lot of quality on show from either team. Both teams having plenty of possession without doing much. United slowly started to have more urgency to their play which resulted in a couple of opportunities.
United Opportunities.
The two best chances United created both fell for the man we would have wanted to, Fletcher.
The first one was a tricky one to control the finish but I would have expected Fletcher to have at least hit the target. United actually keep possession well and find some space for Levitt to deliver an excellent ball to the back post for Fletcher.
Fletcher does really well to peel onto the back of Stewart. This makes it incredibly difficult for the Aberdeen defender to know where he is. McGrath's positioning (in the D) does enough to attract McCrorie away from the back post which allows Fletcher more space to work in. United have good numbers forward on this attack. In this freeze frame, we have plenty of players in decent positions if any balls broke out to the edge of the box or if the ball went wide for a cross.
The 2nd opportunity comes from some lovely 3rd man runs. Harkes gets in behind and fires a ball across but McCrorie does really well to stop the ball going to Fletcher or putting the ball into his own net.
Firstly, the build up is good. Anaku does well to control the ball then link the play to Levitt. Scales goes tight on Anaku. Harkes recognises the space in behind Scales and runs into it. The Aberdeen left wing back doesn't recognise the danger. Levitt in space has time to play a quality pass into this space. Fletcher is in a position to affect Stewart from stepping over.
Once Harkes is in behind, Fletcher's run needs to be across McCrorie to give him the space for the tap in. By running alongside him, it becomes a straight race which McCrorie wins. Harkes ball could have more pace on it but if Fletcher's run is across the defender then it's a tap in. I also think Harkes could have took a shot himself here.
Once United started upping the tempo/urgency, we started to look like a decent team who was capable of creating opportunities. This was done by just having an increase in desire to run off the ball and provide options for the man on the ball. Getting players into higher positions and playing quickier makes such a difference.
Here's another example. Fletcher ends up with a tame header right at the keeper but the play before hand is quick and with intent. Players getting into better positions to receive the ball between the lines. Playing one and two touch football. Having good width and plenty of numbers in the box for the cross. All these things make it easier to create chances.
Of course we are chasing the game so we are becoming more desperate to throw bodies further forward but being more positive and brave on the ball in the final third is how we will score goals. We have tendency to play safe all the time. This doesn't achieve anything and often results in losing the ball anyway.
Full time- Aberdeen 1-0 United
Sadly, this last 15/20 minutes of quickier play couldn't result in an equaliser. Huffed and puffed but never looked likely as we lacked conviction. Mistakes being punished and not taking any chances which came our way. Another narrow defeat in a game where there was nothing between the teams.
My Man of the Match
Since Fox came out demanding more from him, I think DYLAN LEVITT has been excellent. He had a decent cameo at Parkhead and was very good midweek v Kilmarnock. He continued this into this game in my opinion. Brought composure in the middle of the park for us. Started to dictate the play for us in the 2nd half when we had more controlled possession.
Birighitti didn't have much to do apart from the penalty incident. Had a couple of dodgy moments with the ball at his feet. Smith was alright. Looked to get on the ball and advance the play on the right side which is positive but is distribution was poor. Defensively he was fine. Edwards was good I felt. Dealt with Miovski in the main. Graham could have done better in the build up for the goal and had a scary moment when he let Duk get in behind him but in general was solid enough. Good to see the big man back in the line up. Behich worked away but couldn't get forward as much as he did in previous games. Freeman was similar. Tenacity never questioned. Sibbald buzzed around but maybe wasn't at his best. Neat and tidy enough. McGrath couldn't make a great impact in the game. Some nice play at times but not enough. Similar with Middleton who drifted out the game quickly. Fletcher did have some moments of nice link up play but found himself isolated a lot. He needs to be finishing that chance though!
Harkes gave some energy and running ability. Thought he done well when he came on. Anaku was similar. Having players who were willing to run beyond the ball and had enthusiasm to get involved made such a difference. Anaku still very raw. Pawlett couldn't get into the game for the short spell he was on for. Meekison wasn't on long enough to make any impact.
My thoughts
Mixed thoughts on this result. Although our shape was generally decent enough and limited Aberdeen, for the first hour of this game, we lacked real urgency and desire to go win the game, never mind get back into it when we went behind. Once again sloppy mistakes are hurting us it's becoming a really bad habit we can't shake. We don't seem to be able to grind out any result when games are closely contested even a point. No siege mentality! No desire to make sure the least we get is a draw from any game. This was shown by the Celtic result. 2-2 with a few minutes to go, we couldn't even hold out a draw. That is at Parkhead, A place where we clearly have a psychological block but since Fox came in, there's been nearly nothing between the teams in the majority of these games. We haven't been great in these games but we haven't deserved to lose them either. This is hugely worrying as it gives the impression that we don't have the fight or mentality to get ourselves out of trouble!
The break is coming at a good time for United in my opinion. A chance to work with the group for a sustained period of time without distractions. Allow us to refocus and clarify things on the training pitch which will hopefully help us once the action gets back after the world cup.
With no games now until the after the World cup. I'll probably look to do a review of the season so far at some point!
Thank you for reading. I hope you have enjoyed it!


.jpg)








Comments
Post a Comment