Dundee United v St Johnstone Tactical Review
Lineups/Setup
United made three changes from our last game away at Ibrox v Rangers. Mulgrew, Watt and Middleton dropped out for Freeman, Fletcher and Anaku. Fox continued with the 352 formation that he has used since being in charge as interim. Eriksson remained in goal. Smith shifted to a right centre back alongside Edwards and Graham. Behich and Freeman were the wing backs. Levitt, Harkes and McGrath were the three man midfield. Fletcher partnered with Anaku after an impressive cameo at Ibrox.
St Johnstone were unchanged from their last game which ended in a 0-0 at home against Ross County. This meant they continued in their 352/343 formation. Matthews was in goal. A back three of Considine on the left, Gordon in the middle with Mitchell on the right. Wright and Montgomery were the wing backs. Hallberg and McGowan were the centre midfielders with Murphy dropping back into midfield when out of possession. Clark and May were the main strikers.
I was happy with the majority of the lineup. It was really good to see Fletcher back in (even if he didn't look 100%) and Anaku starting. Freeman getting a start was another I was pleased about. With Mulgrew being out, no real surprise to see Smith moved into right centre back. I think Sibbald should have started mostly likely over Harkes in my opinion but can understand to a point why he kept with the same midfield that played against Rangers.
1-0 St Johnstone- Stevie May
Saints took the lead when Considine played a ball in behind the United defence for May who finished nicely past Eriksson.
This goal is a shocker from a United point of view.
Firstly, the throw from Freeman is to Anaku's wrong side. Considine reads the ball well and is able to just intercept easily. Anaku's body weight is on his left side (our right on the picture) but Freeman's throw is onto his right. Considine uses his experience to brush him out the way.
Considine then plays a hopefully ball forward which ends up being a great ball for May to run onto. However, Edwards and Graham get themselves in all kinds of bother without May doing anything apart from running in between them.
Once Considine has won the ball, Graham and Edwards are in a decent position but should look to try and drop to protect the space in behind as there isn't a lot of pressure on Considine. No pressure on the ball= Defence needs to drop. Even more so when there is a threat in behind!
May makes his instinctive run in behind Edwards and Graham. He knows the ball will be played forward so looks to sprint in behind straight away. For some reason, Graham is trying to step to call offside rather than just deal with the run and Edwards is pre-occupied by something on his right even when no players are in that area which widens the gap between himself and Graham.
To emphasis how bizarre Edwards and Graham were for this goal. Look at this clip and focus on one of the three players each time. Edwards steps to his right, Graham holds then steps while May just makes a simple straight line run. It's like a Fifa glitch.
Did Edwards shout step and Graham stepped too late? is that why they are out of sync? even if that was the case, remember.... IF NO PRESSURE ON THE BALL THEN WE NEED TO DROP ESPECIALLY WITH A THREAT IN BEHIND! If we were trying to play offside when no pressure on the ball then we deserve to get caught out as that's high risk and in our current form, No risks should be taken. Run with May and not allow it to be an easy goal.
2-0 St Johnstone- Melker Hallberg
Saints doubled their lead when May picked out Hallberg who passed the ball past Eriksson from just inside the box.
Again it comes from a ball just played over the top by Saints. Graham has went to win the header and is slightly ahead of the rest of the defence. However, Edwards is walking/dandering far too deep. May picks up a nice pocket of space behind Graham.
Graham does well to get back at May but needs to engage the ball more to prevent the pass/cross into our box. Needs to not allow May to pick a pass out. The Saints players are on the front foot more than us which means they can burst into the box first.
McGrath almost gets back to prevent the strike but almost isn't enough. Not enough pressure on Hallberg to stop him from slotting away the 2nd.
What the 2nd goal showed was how passive United were throughout the game. We would usually have plenty of numbers back in positions but no one actually engaging the ball or attempting to win the ball back. Lots of players going the 90% to get up to the ball but not the final 10% of actually putting the Saints player under serious pressure or winning the ball.
Here's a few examples
In the first half, Clark has a shot from the edge of the box which goes high over the bar but he is able to bring the ball down and get a shot away fairly comfortably just outside our box. Plenty of numbers back there but no one actually engaging the ball. Graham ends up stepping up to put pressure on the ball but he still doesn't prevent the shot.
Here's an example when May hits the bar in the 2nd half. Murphy has three United players around him but still manages to get his pass away. Ok he is in the box so the defenders can't be too rash incase of a penalty being conceded but it's still far too passive.
Then once the ball goes to May, Levitt is standing watching. No one preventing the pass to begin with and no one stopping the shot. We were lucky that this time May doesn't score.
United creating a few chances in the 2nd half
In the 2nd half, we started to create a few opportunities mainly done to the fact we had more runners off the ball. Too often our attacking players or midfielders would be too static when we had the ball at the back. This forced us move the ball side to side. This needed to be done with a higher tempo but it wasn't.
In the 2nd half we started to move the ball slightly quicker (still not quick enough) and coupled with more off the ball runners, we were able to cause more problems.
Anaku and Watt both had a shot at goal thanks to runs off the ball. Both of these chances came from a quick, decisive run from the striker into some space. This made the mind up of the player on the ball. The more runners you have off the ball, the more likely the player in possession will play the pass.
Meekison and McGrath began to make clever small runs in between the St Johnstone centre backs and wing back. These runs forced St Johnstone deeper and allowed United more space and possession in the Saints half. Although our tempo still wasn't quick enough, it showed we can create chances if we have quality runs beyond the opponents backline into space.
1-2 United goal- Tony Watt
United got a goal back with less than ten to go when the ball broke to him inside the box after Behich forced a save from Matthews.
It was good for once that United were able to punish a team for a defensive mistake. When Niskanen puts the ball into the box, there's no United player attacking the ball so the Saints defender Mitchell could easily have let the ball go out for a goal kick if they had communicated clearer to him but instead Behich wins the ball by being on the front foot.
Having a players in the box looking for the ball to break to them is also a nice thing to see. It's not just one player, we have a good number of players all in the middle of the goal queueing up to get a strike on goal.
Full time United 1-2 St Johnstone
Defensive mistakes again costing us getting anything from the game. Plenty of possession with no real penetration and lacked urgency for the majority of the match. Better 2nd half performance but still needs to be better if we are to get ourselves out of trouble.
My Man of the Match
There were a few decent performances but I was very much impressed by ARCHIE MEEKISON when he came on. Just his attitude and positivity on the ball gave us more urgency. He was prepared to not only drive forward with the ball and commit Saints defenders but to make runs beyond the ball which is something we lack. He is still young and will make mistakes but he has an enthusiasm for the game that we lacked for the majority of the match. I also think it is about time he gets a run of games in the team.
Eriksson was steady enough. Couldn't do much with the goals but you can see his confidence is slowly building. Smith had plenty of effort but was poor in possession and caught out positional a lot which left Edwards exposed. Edwards was back to his early season form after a few decent performances. Not showing leadership and struggling to do the basics. Graham had an awkward game as well. Clearly not comfortable on the ball which was magnified when in possession. Behich was ok. Has some good moments but also looks lightweight at time. Expecting more from him in all honesty. Freeman gets forward but lacks a bit of aggression at times. Levitt showed a few moments of quality but struggled and was trying to hard to find the perfect pass rather than dictating the play for us. Harkes was non-existent. McGrath worked away. Thought most of our good play came from him but things just not clicking yet for him. Fletcher looked off the pace or still carrying an injury. Had a few nice link ups with Anaku but he wasn't his usual self. Anaku worked tirelessly. Looked interested, direct and enthusiastic. Still looks rough around the edges but I enjoyed his performance compared to others.
Watt done ok when he came on. Still has his sluggish appearance at times but he did at least look more interested when we had the ball. Good to see him get a goal at least. Niskanen brought a bit of urgency and effort but looks very low on confidence. Middleton didn't do a great deal when he came on.
Thoughts
Certainly not the start Fox would have wanted. We continue to make the same mistakes and don't seem like getting that first win anytime soon. Sloppy goals, lethargic in possession and teams being able to defend against us fairly easily is a recipe for disaster. Although we did have more of a threat in the 2nd half we still look vulnerable and fragile. A few players seem to be "getting away with it" in my opinion and it's not to suggest it's directly their fault for our form this season but when confidence is low and results aren't going our way then maybe a few of these usual starters need to be taken out of the team for their own good.
For the next game, I would like to see Meekison in from the start. I think it's time Sibbald returned to the starting line up as well as he didn't appear to have done much wrong in his earlier games but hasn't played much since Alkmaar. Even players like Niskanen or Cudjoe would be an option for me. We've persisted with too many for too long. Options may be limited in certain positions but that doesn't mean we can't make changes to take guys out.
Aberdeen at home may suit us as they have been fairly decent this season. They will be high on confidence and backed by a big away crowd. No expectation will be on United so we can play the underdog card. That's my theory anyway but United really do need to get a result sooner rather than later or we will be in for a long season.
Next up Aberdeen at home. Tough game but we need to be getting something from it!
As always, thank you for taking the time to read this review.
Comments
Post a Comment