United v St Mirren Tactical Review
United v St Mirren Review
Lineups/Setup
United made three changes from last weeks defeat at Tynecastle. There was a change in goal with Birighitti dropping out for Eriksson. Levitt and Fletcher came in for Graham and Cudjoe. We played in a 433 formation with Eriksson in the goal and a back four of Smith, Edwards, Mulgrew and Behich. Levitt playing the sitting role with McGrath and Harkes in more advanced positions in the centre of midfield. Watt played on the left with Middleton on the right. Fletcher was the lone striker.
St Mirren made one change from their 1-0 win against Ross County last time out. In came Gallagher, who was back from suspension and O'Hara. They replaced Shaughnessy and Kiltie. Saints played in a 352 formation with Carson in the goal, a back three of Dunne on the left, Gallagher in the middle and Fraser on the right. Tait was the left wing back with Strain on the right. A midfield three of Erhahon, O'Hara and Baccus with Main and Ayunga up top.
Early Stages
St Mirren almost scored after 90 seconds or so which was a big concern early on. When teams have been under pressure with recent results, you want to see a reaction, an alertness to show they are wanting to make up for the previous results. This, so early into the game, is not the start we were looking for.
A quick throw-in which we are slow to react to and it's a free header for Ayunga who should score. We weren't switched on.
St Mirren started better and were snapping into challenges quicker. United were slow and wanted to take too many touches on the ball. We did however start to slowly play our way into the game. We were having some good possession but not doing much with it.St Mirren Counter Attacking
St Mirren were happy to allow United possession at the back with Edwards, Mulgrew or Levitt if he dropped deeper to receive the ball as they would drop back into a good defensive shape. They compacted the space and prevented United being able to play through them. If they won the ball, they would look to counter attack quickly.
This was shown from their "offside goal" they had where Ayunga was played in behind. United lose possession then are slow to counter press the ball. This allows St Mirren to play some quick short passes then look for the longer pass in behind the United defence.
St Mirren goal
St Mirren took the lead after countering from a turnover of possession. This ironically came during United's best spell of the game.
St Mirren started the better but it was an even game for the majority of the first half. United grew into the game and started to get into dangerous positions but seriously lacking quality in the final third. Saints hitting United on the counter during our best spell of the half summed us up.
United change of shape.
At half time, McGrath was replaced with Cudjoe as we changed shape to a 352. Smith moving into the right of the back three alongside Edwards and Mulgrew. Middleton playing as an unorthodox right wing back and Behich on the left. Cudjoe was playing behind the front two in a number 10 position. Watt now through the middle with Fletcher.
2nd goal St Mirren goal
3rd goal
St Mirren got their third again from a counter attack. From our free kick, They clear their lines then are able to play a nice ball down the line. Brophy does well to put the ball into some good central space and Greive gets to the ball before the keeper and passes the ball into the net.
Full time United 0-3 St Mirren
Small spells of positive play but overall that was abysmal. Outbattled (again), out worked (again) and far too passive in everything we do. St Mirren deserved to win and looked a well organised outfit who were dangerous on the counter. United looked disjointed and let's face it.. A Shambles.
My Man of the Match.
I may have to stop doing this part of the blog because for the third game running, I'm struggling to pick anyone who deserves it. I'm going to give it to the nice gentleman who noticed I had dropped my bank card in the corridor of the George Fox before the game. Whoever you are...Thank you! But on a serious note, no one deserves it for me.
Eriksson didn't give me much confidence with his performance sadly. Not sure if he could do much with the first or second goals but similar to Birighitti, every shot on target seems to go in. The third, he seems indecisive.
Smith needs taken out the team. I like Smith and his work ethic but his confidence is clearly shot (like most players to be honest) You can see he doesn't want to play certain passes in case of losing possession and getting criticism from the stands so instead he plays safe which if anything is worse. Edwards and Mulgrew both struggled with Ayunga and Main's physical play. Both looking a shadow of the players they were last season. Behich looked erratic. Tried too hard to niggle with Saints players. Was always going to get subbed or sent off after the booking.
Levitt doesn't look interested and certainly doesn't like the physical battle. Harkes non-existent. Lots of running but no substance. McGrath was doing ok and shouldn't have been subbed at half time in my opinion but he still wasn't great. Watt looked like he was interested at times in the first half but fell into his usual habit of giving up and not working hard enough for the team. Middleton looked ok first half but 2nd half looked frightened to do anything. Fletcher had a few half chances 2nd half but he needs better service and support. Isolated.
Cudjoe couldn't really get into the game much as he was struggling for space in the no.10 position. Niskanen as usual works hard but really lacks any quality to make the difference. He had two decent opportunities to get us back in the game. Clark had a few decent touches but again struggled to get anything into feet due to a congested midfield area.
My thoughts
Goes without saying, we are in a rut. We can't score, we don't have balance in the team and we can't defend to save ourselves. Every mistake is getting punished and we have a softness to us. Vulnerable and passive. There's no aggression in the team. None whatsoever. No on. We just look weak mentally and physically. Any time a team goes forward currently, it looks like they will score while we have to work incredibly hard to create any half chance that comes our way.
I wasn't overly impressed with the lineup Ross put out (Easy in hindsight for me to say this I know) and I certainly wasn't impressed by taking McGrath off at half time. The change of shape was an attempt to get back into the game by matching up with St Mirren's shape which is fair enough but some players stayed on the pitch for far too long. He needs to find a system that gets us solid again and build from there. He needs to pick a more balanced team. We desperately need a defensive midfield to compliment the "footballers" we have in midfield.
The players are not giving enough. Not enough taking ownership for their performances. Safe passes with no tempo, scared to try anything. Too many playing on reputation rather than merit. Too many "bluffers" in the team. Reaction to losing the ball is so poor and defensively were are exposed so much but need to be doing better individually as well. Overall not good enough.















Comments
Post a Comment