United v Livingston Tactical Review

Dundee United v Livingston Review 

United v livi

 Lineups/Setup 

United made three changes from the AZ game. McGrath came in for the suspended Harkes, Graham came in for Mulgrew and McMann for Freeman at left back. We setup in a 4231 formation with a back four of Smith and McMann as full backs with Edwards and Graham at centre back. Levitt and Sibbald were at the base of the midfield with McGrath playing more advanced. Watt continued on the left with Middleton on the right with Fletcher through the middle again as the lone striker. 

Livi made one change from their last game against Rangers. Montano came in for Cancar. Livi setup in a 433. George was in goal with a back four of Devlin, Fitzwater, Obileye and Montano. Holt, Omeonga and Kelly were the midfield three with Pittman and Shinnie supporting the lone striker of Nouble up top. 

Lineups

Non-event

I'm not going to hang about on this review of the first half. It was a non-event. Neither team created a great deal and there wasn't much football getting played. Livingston were more direct and looked more likely and United were too slow in possession. 

There were only two tactical problems I felt we had in the first half. Firstly, we were allowing the ball into Nouble too easily but I will come on to that and secondly, Fletcher being too isolated. Fletcher is a player who relies heavily on support and service. With Watt and Middleton playing so wide we then needed Sibbald and McGrath to get up centrally into the half spaces to get closer to Fletcher. Too often this wouldn't happen. Here's an example where there is plenty of space for a midfield runner to burst into and link with Fletcher but no one did. 
Isolated Fletcher
 
Amazingly, I actually think we had too much width in the first half. Watt and Middleton would stay so wide with the full backs supporting that we desperately needed penetration through the middle. Livingston seemed quite happy to let us go wide knowing they were 2v2 and any crosses that came into their box would only really have one United target attacking it. 

This is the alternative options. So with Watt and Middleton providing the width then McGrath and Sibbald can move into the half spaces and make their runs from there. They could also support Fletcher from these positions. 
Attacking shape

But what would end up happening was this.
Attacking shape
With the game being very transitional, both McGrath and Sibbald couldn't connect with Fletcher enough. The wide players would provide the width but with no central penetration it was comfortable to Livi who could then force us backwards. 

We needed to find a solution. I think the solution should have been to have Middleton and Watt coming infield, closer to Fletcher. They could still make their runs wide and drift into space but it meant Fletcher wasn't isolated as much. This would hopefully give United more control in the middle of the park as well. Width would be provided by Smith and McMann. 
Solution

Obviously it's easy me saying this but I just felt we needed to get players closer to Fletcher and if it couldn't be the midfielders then get the wide players closer to him. 

Half time United 0-0 Livingston 

Livi looking the more likely and looking far more interested than United were. United were slow and lethargic on the ball with no movement off the ball to provide passing options. Everything in front of the Livingston defence who were comfortable enough to deal with anything United done. Out of possession, we looked slightly passive and didn't have the same urgency in our press that we did on Thursday. 

Livingston goal 

Livingston took the lead early in the 2nd half from a powerful run from Nouble which forced Birighitti into a decent save. McMann then wasn't able to clear properly before being robbed by Devlin who passed to Montano who unleashed a driving shot. 



Firstly, we didn't get good enough pressure on the ball. This allowed the Livingston player too much time to look up and play a decent pass up to Nouble who has pinned Graham. McMann was originally trying to deal with the run of Shinnie then tries to help Graham out but Nouble is just too strong and tricky for both United defenders. 

No pressure on ball
Nouble pinning Graham

Birighitti got a good block and McMann struggled to get the ball away and is robbed by Devlin who plays to Montano. United aren't quick enough to put pressure on the ball. Too many players walking out of the box in this moment. 

No pressure again

Question marks possibly over of Birighitti, who was still adjusting his position after the first shot but that doesn't take away from the lack of pressure on Montano's shot.

Struggling to deal with Nouble 

As we saw from their goal, Nouble was dominant against Graham and Edwards who both just couldn't get to grips with the Livi striker. His sheer size and strength just meant he could pin the centre backs easily and use his body brilliantly to turn and manipulate the defender. 
Here's two examples from the 2nd half. Nouble being able to pin both Edwards and Graham. 
Nouble

There are two ways to prevent this from happening and United done neither for the majority of the game. The first way to stop this would be to stop the ball from source. Putting pressure higher up the park to prevent Livingston from playing quality passes up to Nouble. Not allowing Nouble to bring the ball down on his chest or playing into his feet. 
The second way to prevent this is by having someone in front of him. Levitt could have positioned himself in front of Nouble to prevent these passes going into him. This would have helped the centre backs from getting pinned by Nouble. 
By United not doing either of these tactics, Nouble caused havoc. 

Substitutes making an impact 

After the Livingston goal, Ross made two quick changes. Niskanen and Cudjoe came on for Middleton and Sibbald. This meant McGrath dropped slightly deeper alongside Levitt. Cudjoe went onto the right hand side with Niskanen on the left. Watt would go into a no.10 position but would drift over to the left hand side like usual. 

After Subs

These changes gave us more attacking intent. Now we had more energy on the wings and more urgency to actually make something happen. This also provided us with some much needed movement higher up the park. I felt Watt came more into the game when he was able to play the drifting role behind Fletcher. Rather than being fixed out wide, he was able to cleverly move into positions depending on how the play developed. It also meant he could get himself into dangerous positions or to create opportunities for others. 
Both of his chances were an example of this. 

The first one comes from a McMann cross into the box. Previously Watt would have been out wide or looking to link up with McMann but instead he is making a late run into the area and looking to support Fletcher. The ball falls for him and he works the shooting opportunity well but just can't find the finish. 
Watt chance
Watt chance

For the 2nd chance he starts in a no.10 position but looks to make a run down the left channel. Some link up play with Niskanen (and a small break of the ball) then he is able to drift inside which ends up allowing him to get a shot away. 
He should do better with the shot but considering Watt hardly got many chances in the 2nd half of last season and here is he is having two in one game it's a small positive. I also think Watt in this position would allow the link up play between Fletcher and himself to prosper. Both are intelligent players but require support around them. This could be an idea for the future?! 

Cudjoe 

Cudjoe created problems for Livingston with his trickery and quick feet. This opened up space for United as it forced Livi to double on him at times. He would find himself in nice pockets of space which made him difficult to pick up. 
Cudjoe

The thing I liked so much about Cudjoe was his positivity and direct style on the ball. He played without fear and wasn't intimidated by the Livingston defenders physicality. His first thought is to beat the man then get a shot away if possible. 

Other players would have found themselves in this position and looked to play wide or even backwards but Cudjoe had the confidence to fire in a dangerous shot. This sort of positive play was sorely lacking in the first half. 
Cudjoe 

Full time United 0-1 Livingston 

A disappointing performance and result. After the highs of Thursday, this was always going to be a tough game but for the first hour or so, United just didn't do enough. We had a slight improvement once Cudjoe came on but in general, we looked lacklustre. Livingston are an awkward team to play against but they worked harder than us and in my opinion were well deservant of their win. 


My Man of the Match 

Easy answer..... Matthew Cudjoe! The only player who was willing to drive at his defender and commit them. His enthusiasm and directness got United back in the game almost single handedly. His much needed energy caused Livi problems down the right hand side. 

Birighitti dealt with what he needed to and had a good save from Pittman in the 2nd half. Possibly could have done better with their goal. Smith defensively was fine but his quality on the ball was lacking. Edwards and Graham both struggled at times with Nouble and needed to be more positive when in possession to step in when Livi dropped back into shape. McMann was ok first half but had a poor 2nd. Similar to Smith, his quality on the ball was lacking. Levitt was outstanding v AZ but he very poor v Livi. Looked uninterested and looked lethargic. Even from dead ball scenarios his quality was poor. Sibbald battled away but struggled to get into the game in possession. McGrath was couldn't get into the game. When he was moved deeper, he started to get on the ball more but didn't have a great impact on the game. Middleton looked tired and never really ran at the Livi defence much. Watt was poor first half but became more interested in the 2nd half once changed role. Probably should have scored. Fletcher was isolated too much but battled away against Obileye and Fitzwater. 

Niskanen wasn't great on the ball when he came on but his energy at least provided more urgency. Clark didn't make much of an impact when he came on. 

My Thoughts

I praised Ross for his tactics/selection v AZ but I felt he got it wrong this time. Without wholesale changes, I thought we needed freshness especially in the final third. A lot of the team looked leggy and lacked the same intensity from Thursday. Against any team but mostly Livingston, we need energy and players capable of battling for every ball. Just felt we had too many passengers who weren't able to match Livi's energy levels. This was shown once we brought Cudjoe and Niskanen on. Although Niskanen wasn't anywhere near as effective as Cudjoe was, both brought more energy to the team and a desire to at least run and make it difficult for Livi's defence compared to Middleton and Watt. We severely lacked Harkes in the middle of the park for energy but he had options to provide this energy. Smith could have been moved in there or Meekison could have been an option also. 

We were outworked and outfought by a team who make it very difficult for the opposition to get any momentum. Although we created more once Cudjoe was on, United didn't do enough. We didn't match their work rate or appetite for the game. It does show that we can never get complacent. No team is good enough to pick and chose when they want to play and expect to get away with it. 

Watt

Next up, Only AZ away! What could possibly go wrong?!

Thank you for taking the time out to read this! 










Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Kilmarnock Tactical Preview

Tactical Review of United 21/22

Hearts v United Tactical Review