United v Hearts Review
Lineups/setups
United continued with the 352 setup but made some personnel changes from their last outing against Dundee two weeks ago. Out dropped McDonald and McNulty with McMann and Mochrie coming into the side. The back three remained unchanged with Mulgrew in the centre with Edwards on the right and Graham on the left. McMann came in on the left side with Niskanen switching to right wing back meaning Smith moved inside into the centre of midfield alongside Levitt and Mochrie. Watt and Clark was the partnership up top.
Hearts made four changes from their Scottish cup semi-final win over Hibs last week. Out dropped Halkett, Kingsley, Halliday and Simms with Moore, Cochrane, McEneff and Ginnelly coming into the side. Hearts setup in a 343 formation. Sibbick was the centre of their back three with Moore and Cochrane alongside him. MacKay-Steven and Atkinson were the wing backs with Haring and McEneff playing in centre midfield. McKay and Ginnelly would play either side of Boyce up top.
United started the game fairly well. We won a corner after 16 seconds and probably should have scored when Graham was free in the six yard box from that corner. United were pressing high to begin with preventing Hearts from playing out from the back and forcing them to go long which suited the United backline. This also didn't allow Hearts to get any momentum and rhythm in the game early.
Here's an example of our good early pressing on the Hearts backline. Long ball played forward by United but both strikers are up putting pressure on the Hearts defence which forces a mistake. The ball breaks into midfield where Smith is quick to pick up the 2nd ball. This move doesn't come of anything but it shows that pressing Hearts and not letting them have easy possession could result in turnovers and opportunities for United to attack.
Clark chance and Levitt Goal
Just before Levitt scored, Clark had a great chance to score which produced an excellent save from Gordon from point blank range. United's movement in this attacking move was fairly good with both strikers linking up and dragging the Heart defence around.
I liked Clark's movement for this chance. Looking to get in between the Hearts defenders and not allowing himself to be marked easily. These are the sorts of runs we need more of when in these attacking positions. It was good to see decent numbers in box for the cross as well.
Levitt goal
United kept the move alive and didn't allow Hearts to get organised properly. Clever from Levitt to run off his man and burst into the space. Then he just takes over and produces some magic! Hearts defenders could have done better but from a United point of view, It's a great goal again from Levitt.
After the initial 15 minutes where United done well. United began to drop deeper as the half wore on. The Hearts back line began to have easier possession which allowed them to get into a rhythm and get their attacking players in higher positions up the park. This dropping deep tactic can work if we are trying to set traps for Hearts to play into then looking to counter quickly from there but it just appeared to be dropping deep for the sake of it. The game did remain fairly scrappy but Hearts were beginning to control possession more.
Haring influence
With United beginning to drop deeper, Haring became a big influence for Hearts. His positioning meant he was allowing the more attack minded players to get into higher positions while he stayed and protected the back three. This positioning as the deep lying midfielder meant he could receive the ball between the United strikers and midfield in space.
Hearts were clever with their movement, that if a United midfield stepped up to put pressure on Haring then it could open up space for the likes of Woodburn, McKay or even Boyce dropping deep.
Here's an example of this. McKay has dropped deep to get the ball off the Hearts back line. Levitt is attracted to Haring leaving space behind the United midfield and in front of the defence. Woodburn makes an intelligent run into this space. McKay breaks the line with the pass which allows Woodburn to receive in behind the lines of the United team.
From the half hour mark, Hearts began putting real pressure on United. Controlling possession and finding their attacking players in good positions. Ginnelly was starting to make an impact with runs in behind the United defence. McKay and Boyce were interchanging well and causing problems with their movement. There was a sense of inevitability that Hearts would score.
Hearts equaliser
Hearts got their goal just before half time. A United cross is easily collected by Gordon who quickly throws out to Ginnelly, who turns Graham well on the half way line. Ginnelly drives forward into the United box then appears to have missed the chance to get a shot away. United scramble players back and force Hearts out of the box but nice link up play from Atkinson and Woodburn allows a crossing opportunity for which Boyce is able to score from.
There's a few mistakes in this goal from a United point of view. Firstly, Once Gordon has the ball in his hands, could we get someone standing in front of him to slow him down or prevent the quick throw. This is a small thing but Gordon has previous of throwing out quick (Boyce's goal at Tannadice in the last game is a good example) Ironically we started doing this in the 2nd half when Gordon had the ball in his hands. Graham done it at least twice to prevent the quick throw.
Secondly, Graham gets caught being too tight to Ginnelly. He is too eager to win the ball and in this scenario he probably should have been patient as he had supporting players close enough around him to help win the ball if he just held Ginnelly up.
Once Ginnelly is in the box, United do well to get numbers back with Mulgrew doing well originally to not over commit and to slow him down. Levitt then helps by forcing him backwards.
Once the ball goes out the box, United try to organise while still putting pressure on the ball but we allow a pass into Woodburn's feet.
Some miscommunication from Levitt and Graham allows Atkinson to overlap Woodburn and get an unopposed cross into the box. Neither deal with the run.
I think Mulgrew should be closer to his front post to try and prevent the ball from going across the face of goal. If he is a step to his left, I reckon he clears the cross. Boyce isolates Edwards really well to get in front of him. Siegrist doesn't cover himself in glory here. Boyce adjusts to put Hearts level.
An avoidable goal that Hearts made look so simple. Plenty of bodies back but just not dealing with the cross.
Half time United 1-1 Hearts
A half split into two. The first 20-25 minutes, United were decent enough. Looking to engage with Hearts higher up the park and trying to get forward quickly but from the 30 minutes onwards, it was all Hearts as United fell right out the game. They controlled the possession, were dragging United all over the place with their movement and speed. Frustrating to concede just before half time, If we had managed to hold out until half time then it would have made a difference.
Early 2nd half battles
In the early stages of the 2nd half, both teams were working hard and battling away to gain control. The game was scrappy with neither team able to put any real passing combinations together. United were looking to get the wing backs more advanced with Niskanen driving at the Hearts defence twice early in the 2nd half and McMann driving forward and forcing a save from Gordon. Hearts at times were looking to go more direct with Ginnelly playing more advanced than Boyce. This gave them an outball and could hit early balls into space behind the United defence which would allow Ginnelly to chase them and get Hearts up the park.
This was shown from this Hearts chance. United lose possession, Hearts play a quick ball over the top which has Mulgrew and Edwards scrambling due to the pace of Ginnelly. Boyce is able to pick up the 2nd ball and play to Ginnelly in the wider position who then gets a good shot away which Siegrist does well to save.
This direct play and pace of Ginnelly clearly scared the United back three and made them very uncomfortable. United began to drop deeper again after this chance to protect the space in behind and allow Hearts to have the ball in front of our shape.
Ginnelly goal
With United sitting deeper, it allows easy possession for the Hearts back line, which is fine as there shouldn't be much space in behind for any Hearts runners so any straight ball forward should be deal with by United. Apparently not!
With a threat in behind and no pressure on the ball, they definitely need to drop to deal with the ball. The ball does hold up slightly but there are no excuses for conceding this sort of goal.
Couldn't get a clear picture of the United setup when the ball is kicked but this blurry picture is the best I could get. Mulgrew is attracted to Boyce so can't cover the run of Ginnelly. Edwards doesn't drop quick enough to deal with his runner. Both defenders found wanting. Neither looked like they wanted to deal with Ginnelly due to his pace. Siegrist possibly could come for it as well but due to the ball holding up, I can understand why he doesn't come for it.
Ginnelly's first and second touch takes Siegrist and Mulgrew out of the game and leaves him with an easy finish. Poor goal from United point of view. Simple but effective from Hearts.
After the Hearts goal, United found some urgency and tempo to our play and began to create a few decent opportunities. Freeman had a shot saved by Gordon after a good move down the left. McMann put in a good ball across the face of goal that was cleared by a Hearts defender. Although we weren't dominating Hearts, we were looking more dangerous.
Edwards goal
United managed to get that equaliser. From a throw-in on the left hand side, United work the ball well to Edwards on the right who cuts inside and fires a shot passed Gordon.
Nice play from United in the build up, working the ball from one side of the park to the other. By creating triangles and quick, one touch passes, United were able to open up space for Edwards to step into.
Once Edwards gets the ball, Freeman begins going towards the touchline to get maximum width and to provide a passing option for Edwards. This effects MacKay-Steven as he needs to hold his position and can't go and press the ball. Similar to Cochrane, he is having to mark Watt at the edge of the box so can't engage with the ball either. If Freeman and Watt aren't in these positions then Edwards could be closed down quicker but instead if allows him enough space and time to rocket a shot passed Gordon.
The game became stretched with plenty of space for both teams to exploit. United getting ourselves into some decent positions but lacking cutting edge. Hearts looking more dangerous on the counter. Meekison and McNulty are on at this point as United looked to freshen it up. Simms has replaced Ginnelly to provide more of a physical threat.
Hearts winner
As the game was more stretched both teams had opportunities to get the winner. United to looked to counter first but the move broke down. Hearts then countered us and a nice pass from McKay with an excellent run from Simms resulted in the winner.
When Watt receives the ball he has some space to drive into and has Freeman bursting the gut to support him on the outside. He could play Freeman down the line or even look for a pass into the space for McNulty who is looking for that run but Watt moves inside. Look at Moore's body shape (circled) and compare with Mulgrew later on. His body is open so he can see the run of McNulty then cover it.
When Watt comes inside, it opens up a pass to Meekison who is supporting from deep but Watt delays the pass ever so slightly which slows the attack down.
The pass is also slightly behind Meekison which doesn't allow him to drive onto the ball with pace. This forces him to come back inside where he loses the ball.
When Hearts win possession and play the ball to McKay, Levitt needs to cover across to put pressure on him and not let him drive unopposed into our half. (McKay wasn't even going at a high pace)
McNulty ends up being the closest to McKay when he plays his pass. With still no real pressure on McKay he is able to play a clever through ball in behind for Simms. The run from Simms is great. Darting across the defence to make sure he stays onside. Diagonal run for a straight pass.
For me Mulgrew's body shape in this moment is very poor. He can't see where Simms is and again is too distracted by Boyce it seems. Graham probably should just track the run of Simms rather than trying to play offside. Siegrist does get beaten easily at his near post.
Full time United 2-3 Hearts
Quality going forward the big difference. When United pressed Hearts and looked to win possession higher up the park, then we looked capable of causing problems and making life comfortable for the Hearts defence but for too much of the game we sat too deep and allowed Hearts to get into a rhythm and gain control. Going forward Hearts had so much variety compared to United. The pace of Ginnelly, the trickery of McKay and the cleverness of Boyce was too much for United. Simms then brought a physicality to Hearts that United just don't possess.
The way I would describe this performance- The good, the bad and the ugly
There were spells when we looked decent. Playing with a tempo and an urgency which makes us look dangerous going forward. Putting pressure on Hearts and forcing errors high up the park then countering from there.
Sadly for the Majority of the game, We were passive and allowed Hearts too much time and space on the ball. Dropping deep and not engaging the ball enough.
There was also lots of ugly battling going on where the game was stop start and no real football was played by either team.
The good play gets outweighed by the larger spells of poor play.
My Man of the Match
I'm going to give it to DYLAN LEVITT for his goal in the first half. He doesn't score tap-ins. I think we looked better when he was on the ball and controlling things. He did drift out the game for spells but at least you felt something could happen when he is on the ball.
Siegrist again was questionable with the goals and hasn't looked comfortable for some time now. Edwards struggled with the ball in behind and couldn't get to grips with McKay. He took his goal well though. Mulgrew was poor I thought. Caught trying to be too clever and concentrating on other things rather than just defending. Graham was uncomfortable and struggled with the movement of the Hearts front line. Niskanen couldn't get into the game much and struggled to get forward. McMann was better than some of his previous performances which was a positive. Smith worked hard but lacked quality in the middle to help us keep the ball. Mochrie drifted in and out of the game. Some nice touches and drove forward with the ball but would go missing for spells. Clark struggled to get into the game. Watt was poor as well.
Freeman worked hard on the right but looked slightly rusty on the ball. Meekison showed some positive touches when he came on. McNulty didn't make any impact on the game. Same with Sporle near the end.
Thoughts
Very frustrating result especially after starting so well. Glimpses of decent play but mistakes got punished. Courts needs to change his strategy because the dropping deep tactic (whether the players or from the manager) hasn't been working. We play better when we are on the front foot and going for teams. Sitting back and letting teams come onto us, is a dangerous game. Amazingly. 4th is still there for us but we need to cut out the silly goals and most importantly need to learn how to keep a hold of a lead.
Next up, Motherwell at home on Saturday. Big game! If we want to get 4th place then this would be a massive game to win. Motherwell haven't been on great form but it will still be a tough game!
As always, thank you for reading and I hope you have enjoyed this review.
Comments
Post a Comment