Dundee Derby Review

 United v Dundee Review 

Derby review

Lineups/setup

United were set up in their usual 352 formation, although at times, especially in the first half, we looked to be playing a 4231/433 to try and match up with Dundee. United made no changes from their draw last week v Hibs so that meant that Graham, Mulgrew and Edwards continued as the back three. Niskanen and Smith providing the width as wing backs. McDonald and Levitt sitting to allow Clark to link with the strikers, McNulty and Watt. 

Dundee made two changes from their draw with Aberdeen last week. In came Adam and Anderson with Elliott and Rudden dropping onto the bench. This meant a change of shape for Dundee. In recent weeks they have been setup in a 352 but for this match they changed to a 433/4231. Byrne would be the sitter in their midfield to allow the other midfielders to push higher up the park. Adam would be given almost a free role to drift into space to receive the ball. McGowan would be on the left but would often come narrow to get involved with the play. Anderson would be in the no.10 position with McMullan providing width on the right hand side. Mullen would be the lone striker looking to feed off scraps played forward. 

Lineups

Opening stages 

As expected, the game started scrappy with plenty of battling going on across the park. Neither team were able to find any real rhythm in the game early on as possession was being turnover a lot by both teams. Dundee looking to press United high up the park to force long balls forward which suited their defenders against Watt, Clark and McNulty. United were playing more direct early on to try and turn the Dundee defence however playing against the wind meant that the ball held up more in the air and we weren't able to get in behind the Dundee defence as easily. 

Early United goal

United won the first corner of the game which was a great opportunity to put a quality delivery into the Dundee box to see how they coped with it. However, Levitt went for a cross to the edge of the box towards McDonald who sent it towards our last man Smith on the half way line. If this was a routine, I don't think it was executed well. However Smith launched the ball back into the Dundee box. With the wind holding the ball up in the air, it deceived Lawlor in the Dundee goal as he came charging out to collect it. Graham gets to the ball first and it's an easy tap finish for Clark.


Firstly, Graham staying up meant we had a physical presence to attack the ball, Graham can not only challenge for the ball but can aggressively win these aerial battles. This meant it could allow other players to work off the 2nd ball and not worry about challenging for the first ball. 

United goal 1

Both Clark and McNulty are on the move looking to play off where the ball may break to. Clark is more alert than his marker and attacks the space in the box. With Lawlor caught out, Clark has the easiest of finishes to make it 1-0. 
United goal 2


Dundee coming into the game.

Dundee began to grow into the game after the United goal. This was done by a few things. Getting Adam on the ball more, winning more 2nd balls in midfield and turning the United defence. 

 Initially Adam was bogged down in the midfield battle and couldn't get on the ball as much as Dundee would have liked but Adam began to drop into a false left back position to get himself on the ball. Although at times it was better than Adam dropped into these positions as we he further away from the United goal, it just allowed him to get a foot on the ball more. 

adam dropping wide
adam false full back
Adam dropping deep

He did however at times start to drift forward into the left half space. This area on the side of the United midfield is vulnerable especially from switches of play as it requires McDonald, Levitt or Clark to cover the ground to press the ball. 
Adam in half space
Adam in half space

If the ball is at the Dundee right back, it would usually be one of our midfielders pressing the ball as the wing back would be occupied by the wide attacking Dundee player. This forces the rest of the United midfield to cover across to protect behind the presser. If Dundee were able to work the ball across to Adam in the far side half space then they it could lead to very dangerous opportunities. (Which we will see later on in the game) 
Adam in half space

They also started to win more 2nd balls in the midfield and managed to get in behind the United defence a few times with the last United defender needing to sweep up any danger or Dundee would have been in with a goalscoring opportunity. They then got their biggest chance of the first half with the ball falling for Mullen in the 6 yard box. 

Originally from a corner, Dundee manage to keep the attack alive and get the ball wide on the left to Marshall who is 1v1 with Smith. The United defence is scrambling around to get organised but with Dundee having good numbers still high in the box, United are struggling. 
Mullen chance
Dundee have a clear overload at the back post with three players unmarked and in a very dangerous position. Too many United players caught too high, looking to counter when we cleared the ball originally or ball watching. Marshall manages to get his cross into the box for Mullen who should score. Big let off for United. 
Mullen chance


Half time United 1-0 Dundee 

For the remainder of the half both teams huffed and puffed but not a great deal of goal scoring chances happening. Dundee probably looked the more likelier to score after United got the opener but neither team had any end product going forward. Not much between the sides as the game was broken up by fouls and breaks in play. No real tempo or flow to the game at this stage. (Although that would change) 


At half time Dundee brought on McGinn who came on for McGowan on that left hand side. This gave Dundee more natural attacking threat as McGinn is more direct than McGowan. More noticeably Dundee left their front three of Mullen, McGinn and McMullan higher to try and create a 3v3 with the United back three. McGinn and McMullan especially would look to exploit the space between the United side centre back and the wing back on their side.  
Dundee Front 3


Just before our second goal, we managed to start winning more 2nd balls and get some composure and control of possession. Although we didn't do much in terms of creating any chances, it was important for United to get a foot on the ball and get some control.  

2nd United goal

Before I get onto the free kick itself, I want to mention one thing that I think United should do more of that we done to win the free kick in the first place and that was taking a quick throw in!  Majority of this season, if United win a throw high in the opposition half, we would take our time of taking it allowing the opposition to get back into shape and any chance of a quick counter is gone! 

However, this time we played a quick throw which didn't allow Dundee to recover easily back into position. This leads to McGhee making a rash challenge, conceding the free kick and an opportunity for United to put a ball into the Dundee box. Taking a quick throw is something so simple but United don't do it enough and slow the tempo down. 
The free kick itself is just quality from Mulgrew. Whether he means it as a shot or a cross, it doesn't matter, the delivery is on the money. 


From a Dundee point of view, I think their defensive line is just ever so slightly too deep. I think they should have been higher by a yard or two to be in line with the wall. By being so deep, it causes havoc for the goalkeeper and means he can't get a clean dive for the ball. 

Mulgrew freekick
Just look how deep the defence are by the time the ball is in the six yard box. Dundee have pretty much got three defenders on the goal line with the goalkeeper having no space to properly extend for the ball. 
Deep defence from Dundee


After the 2nd goal, United started to drop slightly deeper. The wing backs were holding back slightly which allowed some space for Marshall and mainly Kerr to get more time on the ball. This meant that the midfield was having to work harder to pressurise the ball. 

Dropping deeper
Dropping deepr

First Dundee goal 

As United started to drop deeper, Kerr was able to drive forward with the ball. He receives the ball just inside his own half and is able to travel with the ball unopposed into our half easily. Niskanen is pinned back by McMullan so the responsibility of pressing Kerr falls onto the midfield. With Graham also having to deal with the run of McGinn, Anderson is able to run into space. McDonald is too far away to cover Anderson's run. 

Anderson now attracts Mulgrew slightly wide and opens up space between the United defence. McDonald needs to cover the space in front of the defence to prevent any passes into the strikers feet. The distances between the midfield is too much and leaves space to be exploited. 

United get plenty of numbers around the ball but no one puts a challenge in and allows Kerr to dig out a cross. If McDonald was further across to begin with he would have cut out the pass back to Kerr or been able to block the cross. I may also be being harsh on Smith here but I feel he could be helping out Edwards at the back post as he is left 1v1 with Mullen with space to run into. 

Siegrist needs to move his feet to deal with the cross. He just misjudges the cross and puts it on a plate for Mullen to tap in. Maybe Edwards could have been alert to maybe help Siegrist out but it's poor from Benji as it wasn't a difficult ball to deal with as there wasn't a great deal of pace on the delivery. If he moves his feet he collects that fairly easily or gets a better connection on the ball. 
The United defence just look disjointed throughout this move. The distances between units were too far apart and Dundee, to their credit, exploited it well. 

Dundee 2nd Goal 

A minute or so later, Dundee get the equaliser. Dundee work the ball from their right hand side to Adam who receives the ball then drives into left side space that I mentioned earlier that he was looking to get into. 
Adam
As soon as Adam receives the ball, it's clear that he is looking to get a shot away. McDonald is scrambling across to put pressure on Adam but just can't cover that ground quick enough. 
Adam goal

Now originally I thought it took a big deflection hence the lack of an attempt from Siegrist to save it but having watched it back, I have slight sympathy for the goalkeeper. Firstly, his centre of gravity is on his left side. His feet appear to be planted which doesn't help him adjust to the swerve on the ball. He also looks to be blindsided by Edwards so sees the ball late. 
Siegrist centre of gravity

That being said, the ball doesn't swerve that far away from Siegrist and doesn't go into the corner of the net for Siegrist to make no real attempt to make a save. 

Adam goal not in corner of net



With half an hour left in the game, both teams started to "go for it" as space began to open up with the game becoming stretched. United started to look more dangerous with Levitt having a long range strike going narrowly wide. 
We also had a quilt edged chance which fell to McNulty. It's a shame for McNulty as he done so well to create the chance in the first place but when Clark fires the ball back to him 6 yards out, he needs to be finishing that. Smith also had a massive chance as well where Kerr done really well to prevent a certain goal. Both teams had chances throughout the remainder of the game but neither could get that winner.

Full time United 2-2 Dundee 

Probably a fair result. Poor first half from both teams but the 2nd half was much more open and attacking with some good chances for both teams. United being two goals up and only drawing is very frustrating as we created the better chances in the 2nd half to get the win. Credit to Dundee for fighting back from two down but United needed to show more experience to slow the game down to prevent Dundee from hitting back so quickly after our 2nd goal then after their first. 

My Man of the Match 

I don't think anyone really stood out but I'm going to give it to CHARLIE MULGREW purely down to the free kick. Felt he had a decent defensive display but the free kick was the standout moment so he gets my MotM. 
Siegrist looked uncomfortable throughout which is unlike him. Although he has made mistakes recently, the first Dundee goal was a throw back to the mistakes he made back in the championship when he first signed for United. Edwards was decent enough, same with Graham. Smith worked hard on the right hand side and was unlucky not to get the winner. Niskanen didn't have his best game but his effort is still key to us on the left. McDonald showed some good moments but tired. Levitt drifted in and out of the game. Clark worked hard and was proactive enough to score the opener but drifted out of the game. McNulty and Watt both worked very hard but still lacking the quality we are needing from them. 
Surprised we didn't make any subs during the 2nd half especially when the game became more stretched and fresh legs were required. I felt we needed more energy in the midfield and expected Smith to move in there with Sporle or Freeman coming on as a wing back. 

Thoughts

Obviously frustrating not to win the game when we were 2-0 up however in the grand scheme of things to secure top six is still a good achievement. We haven't been as free flowing as we would have liked and we still have issues that need sorted in the long term but all things considered a top six finish is an excellent first season from Courts. 
No game next week as it's Scottish cup semi-final weekend then our next game is yet to be announced so time will tell who our first game in the split will be. 

As always, thank you for reading and I hope you have enjoyed this review. 


















Dundee better in first half. 

half time

early untied 2nd half goal. 

Dees comeback (Adam halfspace) 

Big chances 

My Man of the Match 










Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Kilmarnock Tactical Preview

Tactical Review of United 21/22

Hearts v United Tactical Review