United v Hearts Tactical Review

Dundee United v Hearts Review 


Lineups/setup 

United continued with the 352 setup. We made three changes from the midweek defeat to Livingston. Out dropped Mulgrew, Freeman and Watt. In came McDonald, McMann and Clark. Butcher dropped back into the right side of the back three with Edwards moving into the middle with Graham continuing on the left. Niskanen switched to the right wing back with McMann playing on the left. Smith again playing in centre midfield alongside Harkes and McDonald. Clark and McNulty the partnership up top. 

Hearts were unchanged from their midweek home win against Aberdeen. Neilson in recent weeks has changed his shape from 343 back to a 4231. Halkett and Souttar in the middle of a back four with Atkinson and Kingsley at full backs. Baningime and Devlin were the two sitters to allow McKay, Boyce and Mackay-Steven to drift and connect with the main striker Simms. Due to injuries, they will change to a 343 at times throughout the game. 

Early Hearts goal

In recent weeks, United have hit the opponents with an early goal but this time it was Hearts who hit us. We originally had a decent half chance with Clark. Smith gets in behind and looks to pick someone out in the box. Clark's movement is ok but it needs to be timed better as Souttar reads it easily and manages to put him off enough. Clark needs to do a double movement here to move Souttar and to make it not look obvious where he wants it. 

Double movement- To make a run to move the opponent to then attack the space the opponent has just left. In this example, Clark should either make a run to the back post to then dart in front of Souttar or run front post to then dart off the back of Souttar. 

Souttar does well to put Clark off and the ball ends up with Gordon, who looks to set Hearts off on the counter. United have seven players high up the park at this moment which leaves our back three exposed. We need to have someone getting in front of Gordon to prevent a quick throw and slow him down.

A quick throw from Gordon to McKay and the Hearts counter has begun. The United back three now are having to drop deep to delay the Hearts attack hoping that one of our recovering players can get back to put pressure on McKay. The Hearts pace on the counter prevents this.

 By the time Mackay-Steven receives the ball, United have managed to get a few players back but we are still struggling to be organised. Butcher steps up to engage the ball which opens space behind him for Boyce to make a nice diagonal run into.

Edwards does well to cover the run and with the pass to Boyce slightly wide, United are in an ok position here. The angle is tight for Boyce and Edwards is putting pressure on the shot. Boyce shows his quality by still being able to score from this position. United were stretched throughout this Hearts attack as soon as Gordon got the ball and we were punished. 

Early Hearts Dominance

Hearts were picking off United as we pressed with quick passes and switches of play. United were too passive and slow to pick up 2nd balls which meant Hearts could attack quickly and not let us build any rhythm. This quick play left the United defence isolated in uncomfortable situations with no cover or protection. By having their attacking players high, it meant if they won any individual battle in the United half, they would overload the United defence. If United looked to press high up the park, Hearts could bypass the midfield and get into these types of scenarios. 
The United midfield/wing backs have looked to press high which Hearts have bypassed leaving a 3v3 in the United half. McKay wins the battle with Graham and drives inside. Simms takes Edwards away to create space on the other side. McKay now has two Hearts players supporting to his left against Butcher with Niskanen trying his best to get back which results in him almost scoring an own goal. 

Due to United's press being very lacklustre in the first half, Hearts were able to break lines with penetrative passes from the back. Their main source of joy was from Souttar, who was able to play these  passes into McKay's feet easily. When the Hearts centre back had the ball, they would look to encourage the United wing back on that side to push up onto the Hearts full back, therefore possibly leaving the United centre back 1v1 with the Hearts attacking player.

Here are two examples- Souttar has time on the ball. Atkinson is dropping slightly deeper to encourage McMann higher to open up the pass into McKay who would be left in a 1v1 battle with Graham.

This time, Hearts are deeper in their half with United pressing higher up the park. Again Atkinson has dragged McMann high opening up the pass higher to McKay. McDonald has came across this time to help Graham this time but McKay is still able to drive inside. 

It took United awhile before we found a solution to prevent this. This was achieved by Harkes pushing up to press. The body shape of Harkes press meant Souttar couldn't find that pass into the attacking player and with McMann pressing the full back, Souttar had no easy passing options in front of him.

If the ball was played to the left side of the Hearts defence, Smith would come across and press the ball allowing Niskanen to hold his position and deal with the wide Hearts player. This would usually force Hearts into longer passes or backwards. Halkett is a very good defender but he isn't as comfortable to play penetrating forwards passes compared to Souttar as he is a right footer playing on the left. 


Here's a final example of United pressing well on both sides. Harkes out to prevent forward pass from Souttar who is forced to play sideways. Halkett then goes back to Gordon, who plays a poor pass out to Kingsley which allows Smith to come across and put pressure on the Hearts left back. This forces the error and United win possession.

Half time United 0-1 Hearts 

After an initial first 10/15 minutes were Hearts were dominant, United started to grow into the game. Once we sorted out our pressing strategy, we were able to get a better foothold of the game as Hearts couldn't break our lines as easily.  Although we didn't create any goal scoring opportunities, we were picking up more 2nd balls and making better pass combinations than the early part of the game. Hearts were still the more likely to score and looked dangerous with their pace and cleverness up front. Injuries disrupted their flow as the game became more scrappy. 

Early 2nd half goal 

As quick as Hearts scored the opener in the first half, United scored quickly in the 2nd. A long ball forward breaks for Liam Smith who rockets a shot past Gordon. Nothing too tactical here but a few interesting things. 

The amount of numbers around the ball gave us better chance of winning the 2nd ball as it broke and meant no easy possession gained for a Hearts player either.

Smith is proactive and is on the move, gambling on where the ball may break rather than reacting to where it falls. This momentum means he can drive forward when he picks up the ball.

The wing backs being higher up the park than both our strikers is a worry though. I would want McNulty to be looking to make a run in between the Hearts defenders but instead he doesn't make any run at all. Clark was challenging for the midfield battle so can excuse him to a point but both strikers not anywhere near the goal for any rebounds if Gordon saved the shot. 

By showing more urgency and desire to win the ball and not let Hearts win comfortable possession, we've managed to equalise. 

Clark Penalty

The penalty is similar to the equaliser. Long ball into the Hearts half, decent numbers around the ball looking for where it might break. Clark gets to the ball ahead of Souttar and it's a clear penalty. 

What I like about Clark here is he is similar to Smith for the first goal, Proactive. He isn't standing waiting for the ball to fall to him, he darts into space where he thinks the ball will drop and he gets it. 

Similar to Clark's penalty v Ross County a few months ago, He takes his time once the referee has blown his whistle. With plenty of distractions, it can be easy for players to rush these kicks but Clark again has calmed himself down and took control of the situation by giving himself a few seconds to take the penalty. It may not seem like much but it allows him to clear his mind and concentrate on getting good contact on the penalty. 

 United trying to prevent the switch of play. 

United struggled to deal with the switch of play in the first half and it was clear that in the 2nd, the emphasis was to prevent Hearts from switching the play as easily. This was done by forcing Hearts onto one side of the park and squeezing the play on that side. If Hearts wanted to play the switch, they needed to go backwards then across which allowed United to recover back into their shape. 


This type of pressing resulted in a big opportunity for United to increase the lead. Sibbick has the ball. McNulty puts him under pressure with Clark and McMann supporting the press. The angle of McNulty's run prevents Sibback from playing across the park easily. Sibbick takes a poor touch backwards and McNulty robs him. 


In this position, Clark needs to be clearer on his movement. I personally think he could be looking to make a run into 6 yard box for any shot flashed across from McNulty. 

However, Once Clark holds his position for the cut back, McNulty needs to play a better pass to him. The pace on the ball is too much and slightly behind Clark, I think this is why Clark leaves the ball. Possibly a shout from Niskanen decides this as well. No conviction from McNulty or Clark in this situation when we should have punished the Hearts error. 


United dropping deeper

With United now holding onto a lead, we started to drop deeper to control the space. This started to allow Hearts to have fairly easy possession at the back. Although they weren't able to penetrate through our shape much, it allowed them to build their attacks better and get their players into higher positions. 

Halkett Goal 

United had two warning signs from corners before they equalised. Halkett had an effort saved from Siegrist and Haring headered just wide as Hearts looked dangerous from set-pieces.

The timing of the Hearts runs into the middle of the box with speed is very good. Halkett just gets enough separation from Butcher to get the slight run on him for the header. No man on the post means it trickles into the corner. Plenty of bodies back but a poor goal to concede. 


Full time United 2-2 Hearts 

First 10-20 minutes, Hearts dominated as United struggled to lay anything on them. However, once United settled down and started to get a foothold in the game, it was very even. Injuries clearly disrupted Hearts rhythm but they were always a danger. A draw possibly the correct result with an improved 2nd half performance from United. 

My man of the match 

Although there were some good performances especially in the 2nd half, LIAM SMITH I thought was outstanding throughout. Composed on the ball and driving forward when he got the opportunity. His defensive qualities also were very important with some vital covering and protection given to the defence. His goal was an excellent show for his afternoon's work! 

Siegrist dealt with the majority of what he had to do. Butcher was very good as well, commanding from the back. Edwards struggled to begin with but grew into it like the rest of the team until he went off. Graham was similar. Struggled with McKay at first but got to grips with him as the game went on. McDonald started slow but gave us that composure in the 2nd half we were looking for. Harkes worked away well and showed some nice touches. Niskanen had one of his more quieter games but worked very hard on the right hand side. McMann looked rusty but improved in the 2nd half. Clark took his penalty well but still lacking a bit of cutting edge at times. Same with McNulty who continues to work really hard for the team but just can't get the breaks he needs in front of goal.

Neilson done really well when he came on, aggressive and commanding at the back. Sporle didn't impact the game too much but his effort when he came on was still important to ensuring we didn't lose the game. 

Overall can't complain with the result. Need to start turning these leads into wins as we seem to get in front in games more but let them slip. If we are to get into the top six, we need to grind out a win or two. Next week big cup game v Celtic. Always going to be tough but we need to show a similar attitude to the recent Rangers game at home. 

Thank you and I hope you have enjoyed reading this review! 








Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Kilmarnock Tactical Preview

Tactical Review of United 21/22

Hearts v United Tactical Review