Posts

Dundee United v St Mirren Tactical Review

Image
 Dundee United v St Mirren Tactical Review  Setups/Lineups  United made three changes from our last game, away to Livingston. Mulgrew, Freeman and Anaku dropped out for Edwards, Smith and Pawlett. United started in a 343 formation with Birighitti in goal, a back three of Ayina, Edwards and McMann. Smith and Behich as wing backs. Harkes and Sibbald were the two deeper centre midfielders with Pawlett and McGrath advanced and closer to the lone striker Fletcher.  Not overly disappointed or surprised by the lineup. Did originally wonder if we were playing a 4231 with Behich playing as a winger/wide midfielder and one of Pawlett or McGrath as a narrow winger on the other side with the other one in as a no.10 but once the game started it was definitely a 343.  Was interested to see how Edwards reacted after being dropped in the previous game. Good to see Pawlett back but did find it slightly strange to see him on from the start after being out for a while. Possibly a ...

Dundee United v Aberdeen Review

Image
Dundee United v Aberdeen Tactical Review  Lineups/setup Goodwin made four changes from last week's defeat v Ross County. For his first match in charge, Birighitti was reinstated in goal, McMann, Freeman and Harkes also came into the team with Newman, Smith, Fotheringham and Djoum dropping out of the starting eleven. A new manager saw us return to the 343 formation we've used under Fox. Birighitti was back in goal with a back three of Edwards on the right, Mulgrew in the middle with McMann on the left. Freeman and Behich were the wing backs. Levitt and Sibbald were in the centre of midfield with Harkes and McGrath supporting Fletcher up top.  I was interested to see what lineup Goodwin would put out and wasn't totally surprised by any selections made. I assumed Birighitti was back in goal for experience over Newman. Freeman in for Smith was a slight surprise but was required. At this stage of the season, I'm not bothered by who plays most of the time, it's more about...

United v St Johnstone Review

Image
 Dundee United v St Johnstone Tactical Review  Lineups/Setup United made four changes from the Kilmarnock game in the cup last week. Out dropped McMann, Cudjoe, Middleton and Niskanen. In came Behich, Djoum, McGrath and Fotheringham. For the first time since Fox came in, United moved away from the 343/352 setup to a 433. Birighitti was in goal with a back four of Smith, Ayina, Mulgrew and Behich. Levitt, Djoum and Sibbald were the midfield three with McGrath out on the right hand side and Fotheringham on the left. Fletcher was the lone striker.   I was happy to see a change in shape as I felt the 3 at the back formation had went stale and needed something new. I was ok with the majority of the starting line up but felt there were a few strange decisions. I know McGrath has played as a winger before in his career but I couldn't understand why we threw him out there as he is far better utilised centrally. Bringing Fotheringham in from nowhere was a strange call. Nothin...